Manfred

Tchaikovsky's Manfred is a symphony in four scenes after Byron's dramatic poem, in B minor, Op. 58, composed and orchestrated between May and September 1885.

Genre
Symphonies
Key
B minor
Composed
1885
Description
Symphony in four scenes after Byron's dramatic poem
First performed
11/23 March 1886, Moscow
Catalogue
TH 28 · Op. 58 · ČW 25

The story

The idea of a symphony on Byron's poem Manfred came from Vladimir Stasov, and in 1882 Mily Balakirev passed it on to Tchaikovsky with a detailed programme. In four scenes, it follows Manfred as he wanders the Alps, haunted by his memories of Astarte. Tchaikovsky wrote it at Maydanovo in 1885, and it was first played in Moscow in March 1886.

Subject

The idea for a symphony on the subject of Lord George Byron's poem Manfred: A Dramatic Poem (1817) originated from Vladimir Stasov, who suggested the idea to Mily Balakirev and Hector Berlioz in 1867, although both composers declined to write the music.

However, in 1882 Mily Balakirev returned to the idea and suggested the subject to Tchaikovsky [1]. In a letter of 28 October/10 November 1882, Balakirev sent Tchaikovsky a modified version of Stasov's detailed programme:

1st movement: Before setting out the programme, I should tell you that, like Berlioz's two symphonies (Symphonie fantastique and Harold), your future symphony must have its own idée fixe — representing Manfred himself - which would permeate each movement. And so, here is the content of the programme for the first movement:

Manfred wanders in the Alpine mountains. His life is shattered, but he is obsessed with life's unanswerable questions. In life nothing remains for him except memories. Images of his ideal Astarte permeate his thoughts, and he vainly calls to her. Only the echo from the cliffs repeats her name. Memories and thoughts bum and gnaw at him. He seeks and begs for oblivion, which no-one can give him (F-sharp minor; 2nd theme — D major and F-sharp major).

2nd movement: A mood quite different to the first — the programme: The life of Alpine hunters, full of simplicity, good nature and a patriarchal character. Adagio pastorale (A major). Manfred clashes with this way of life, to which he is himself in such stark contrast. Of course, you should first have a hunter's tune, but you should be particularly careful not to let it descend into triviality. God preserve you from vulgarities like German fanfares and Jägermusik.

3rd movement: Scherzo fantastique (D major). The Alpine fairy appears to Manfred as a rainbow from the spray of a waterfall.

4th movement: (Finale), F-sharp minor, A wild, unbridled Allegro, representing the subterranean halls of the infernal Arimanes (Hell), where Manfred arrives, longing to be reunited with Astarte — a contrast to this infernal orgy will be the summons and appearance of Astarte (now in D-flat major, in the first movement D major). Although there the idea was fleeting, like a memory, and was immediately engulfed by Manfred's suffering, yet here this same idea should appear in a complete and fully realised form. The music should be light, transparent like air, ideal and innocent. Eventually, a return to the Pandemonium, then sunset and the death of Manfred".

In his letter of reply of 12/24 November 1882, Tchaikovsky would not give a definitive response to Balakirev until he had the opportunity to read through Byron's story, and besides which, he wrote: "... for some reason I imagined that your programme would awaken in me a burning desire to reproduce it in music, and so I awaited your letter with great impatience. But when I received it I experienced disappointment. Your programme could in all probability serve as a design for a symphonist inclined to imitate Berlioz; I agree that this scheme might form an effective basis for a symphony in the style of that composer. But at the moment it leaves me completely cold, and when the heart and imagination are not warmed, it is hardly worth setting about composition. To please you I might perhaps, to use your expression, make an effort, and squeeze out of myself a whole series of more or less interesting episodes, in which one would encounter conventionally gloomy music to reproduce Manfred's hopeless disillusionment, and a lot of effective instrumental flashes in the "Alpine fairy" scherzo, sunrise in the violins' high register, and Manfred's death with pianissimo trombones. I would be able to furnish these episodes with harmonic curiosities and piquances, and I would then be able to send all this out into the world under the sonorous title Manfred. Symphonie d'aprés, etc. I might even receive praise for the fruits of my labours, but such composing in no way appeals to me [...] It is quite possible that the abject coolness with which I view your programme is the fault of Schumann. I love his Manfred extremely and am so used to merging in a single indivisible notion Byron's Manfred with Schumann's Manfred, that I cannot conceive how I might approach this subject in such a way as to elicit from it any music other than that which Schumann furnished it with" [2].

Tchaikovsky wrote to his brother Modest about Mily Balakirev's suggestion on 8/20 November 1882: "I'm now having a quite curious correspondence with Balakirev, which he initiated. He is inflamed with the notion that I should write a large symphony on the subject of Manfred" [3].

Tchaikovsky's discussions with Balakirev over Manfred were confined to the aforementioned letters. In October 1884, while Tchaikovsky was staying in Saint Petersburg, it seems that he met personally with Balakirev, who again brought up the subject of Manfred and tried to persuade Tchaikovsky to compose the symphony. In a letter of 30 October/11 November 1884, Balakirev sent Tchaikovsky the programme for Manfred again, copied out for him by Vladimir Stasov. The text is almost identical to the 1882 version. In the margin, however, Balakirev made some emendations, which did differ from the first version of his scheme: "The symphony should be in B-flat minor without B-flat major", "2nd theme in D major, and the second time in D major". The second movement — "Larghetto. G-flat major", it should not be difficult for the orchestra since the tempo should be slow, and the secondary key should be B-flat major or A major". The third movement — "Scherzo. D major". And the fourth movement — "Finale. B-flat minor. D-flat major con sordini" (representing Astarte), "at the end a Requiem, with a final chord on B-flat major... For the last part of the requiem it would be good to bring in an organ". At the end of the programme, Balakirev added the following remarks: "All the movements should include Manfred's own theme; in the Scherzo this theme could be in the form of a trio", and added a list of symphonic-programmatic works of a similar character by other authors; among the suggestions for the first and last movements was Francesca da Rimini, and for the Scherzo — the B-minor Scherzo from Tchaikovsky's Third Symphony [4].

In reply, Tchaikovsky promised to purchase a copy of Byron's poem forthwith: "I will shortly be in the Alpine mountains, where the conditions for successfully depicting Manfred in music would have been very good, were it not for the fact that I am going to visit a friend who is gravely ill [5]. In any case, I promise you that so far as possible I will use all my strength to carry out your wish" [6]. While he was travelling abroad, Tchaikovsky did not start work on the symphony, but the idea of Manfred was not forgotten [7].

Instrumentation

Manfred is scored for a large orchestra, comprising 3 flutes (3rd doubling piccolo), 2 oboes, English horn, 2 clarinets (in A), bass clarinet (in B-flat), 3 bassoons + 4 horns (in F), 2 trumpets (in D), 2 cornets (in A), 3 trombones, tuba + 3 timpani, bell (in A), cymbals, bass drum, tambourine, triangle, tam-tam + 2 harps, violins I, violins II, violas, cellos, double basses + harmonium (or organ).

Tchaikovsky noted at the start of the Pastorale that "The bell should be of medium size and tuned to A. If possible, it should not be placed in the concert hall, but in the closest adjoining room".

Movements and duration

There are four movements, each of which is prefaced in the score with its own programme:

  1. Lento lugubre (B minor, 338 bars)
    Manfred wanders in the Alps. Wearied by the fatal questions of existence, tormented by hopeless longings and the memory of past crimes, he suffers terrible spiritual yearnings. He has delved into the occult sciences and commands the mighty powers of darkness, but neither they nor anything in this world can give him the forgetfulness to which alone he vainly aspires. The memory of the lost Astarte, once passionately loved by him, gnaws at his heart, and there is neither limit nor end to Manfred's despair.
  2. Vivace con spirito (B minor, 555 bars)
    The Alpine Fairy appears to Manfred beneath the rainbow of a waterfall.
  3. Andante con moto (G major, 282 bars)
    Pastorale. A picture of the simple, free and peaceful life of the mountain folk.
  4. Allegro con fuoco (B minor–B major, 491 bars)
    The subterranean palace of Arimanes. An infernal orgy. Appearance of Manfred in the midst of a bacchanal. Evocation and appearance of the spirit of Astarte, who pardons him. Death of Manfred.
Performances of Manfred generally last between 50 and 60 minutes, making it Tchaikovsky's longest purely orchestral work.

Composition

On 9/21 April 1885 he returned to Maydanovo, and while awaiting the libretto for the opera The Enchantress from Ippolit Shpazhinsky, he set about composing the symphony. The sketches were begun in one of his notebooks. However, on 22 April work was interrupted. From a number of letters to Nadezhda von Meck during this period we learn that Tchaikovsky went on a prolonged journey. It was only in early/mid-June, after his return to Maydanovo, that he resumed work on the symphony, as he reported to Anna Merkling [8].

The compositional process is revealed in the surviving sketches. The first and second movements were the first to be written, the sketches for these being found in one of his notebooks. Notes of themes for the finale are to be found further on in the notebook, after which are notes relating to the third movement.

Continue readingShow less 14 more paragraphs

Immediately after the Finale is the note: "End of the symphony, 13/25 May, but much still needs to be done before the end". However, work on the fourth movement continued after 13/25 May, since some pencil sketches for the second theme of the finale were made on a letter from Yevgeniya Novosiltseva, which is dated 15/27 May.

We find the first reference to work on the symphony in letters to Anna Merkling of 4/16 June, and to Nadezhda von Meck and Sergey Taneyev on 13/25 June 1885. In the letter of 4/16 June, Tchaikovsky wrote: "I am now writing an unusual form of symphony..." [9]. "Time flies by so quickly"", he wrote to Nadezhda von Meck: "Back in April I began to make sketches for a long-standing idea for a programme symphony on the theme of Byron's Manfred. Now I am so captivated by this work that the opera will probably be long set aside. This symphony requires from me tremendous effort and labour, since it is a very complicated and serious assignment" [10]. On the same day he wrote to Taneyev, "After some hesitation. I have decided to write Manfred, because I feel that until I have fulfilled the promise that I imprudently made to Balakirev during the winter, I shall not be at ease. I don't know what will come out, but at the moment I'm dissatisfied with myself" [11].

After increasingly having to force himself to take up composition, Tchaikovsky subsequently became captivated by the work. In a letter to Mily Balakirev on the day that he finished the full score, 22 September/4 October 1885, Tchaikovsky informed him: "I set about Manfred rather reluctantly and, if I may be frank, felt that I was obliged to write it, because I promised you, and I made a firm promise... but very soon I became terribly infatuated with Manfred, and cannot remember ever having felt such pleasure in working, which stayed with me until the end" [12].

We can ascertain with complete accuracy the chronology of composition of the symphony using an extraordinary multitude of sources, the provenance of which, however, is complicated by mistakes in the dates given by the author. During May and June, Tchaikovsky travelled a great deal, staying in Moscow and Saint Petersburg, and journeying to Smolensk for the opening of a memorial to Mikhail Glinka.

In a letter to Anna Merkling of 6/18 July 1885, Tchaikovsky wrote: "I am totally immersed in proofs of the opera [13], and also a large new symphony" [14]; in his notebook containing sketches for the finale and third movement is a note, made later than the first (dating from 13/25 May): "Today is 6 July (O.S.), and yet I still have not got very far".

The rough sketches for the symphony were completed in early July.

On 8/20 July, Tchaikovsky told Sergey Taneyev, "For a long time I was quite unwell, through working too much on proofs of the opera... and yet between business affairs and trifling matters, I completed the rough sketches for a symphony, which annoys me a great deal, and I feel the need to rid myself of it as soon as possible" [15]. However, carried away by the work, he did not set the symphony aside, and straight away set about its instrumentation. On 20 July/1 August, he wrote to Emiliya Pavlovskaya: "I had been planning for a long time to write a symphony on the subject of [Byron's] Manfred. And so, in order not to let these three weeks be wasted in idleness, I set about making the sketches for this symphony, and became so carried away, as frequently happens, that I could not stop. The symphony has come out enormous, serious and difficult; it is absorbing all my time, and sometimes wearies me in the extreme; but an inner voice tells me that I am not labouring in vain, and that this will be, perhaps, the best of my symphonic compositions. […] I still have, approximately, some two months' hard work remaining on the symphony" [16].

The scoring of the first movement of Manfred was completed on 12/24 September 1885 (according to the date on the manuscript). At the end of the second movement, the author noted "(End of the scherzo, 22 July 1885)" (O.S.).

However, in his copybook containing sketches of the finale, yet another date appears: "And today is 31 July (O.S.), but oh dear, there's still such a long way to the end!"

Some days later he told Nadezhda von Meck, "I am working on a very difficult, complicated symphonic work (on the subject of Byron's Manfred), which happens to have such a tragic character, that occasionally I turn into something of a Manfred myself. That apart, I am having to squeeze out every last drop of effort from myself. I want so much to quickly bring this to an end, and am using up all my strength... as a result of this, I am absolutely exhausted" [17]. "Never before have I expended such labour and exertion as on the symphony that I am now writing", he told Nikolay Tchaikovsky on 19/31 August 1885 [18].

Even more captivated by the work, Tchaikovsky was very pleased with the fruits of his labour. In a letter to Emiliya Pavlovskaya of 10/22 August, he wrote: "It is my opinion that my symphony will be the best of all my compositions in symphonic form... I am very proud of this work, and want those persons whose sympathy I most value in the world... to experience, when they hear it, a reverberation from the enthusiasm with which I wrote it" [19]. We read in a letter to Nadezhda von Meck on 31 August: "My symphony is going so well that I am hopeful that it will be finished by the end of the month. I hope that my labour and agonies have not been in vain, and that it will turn out to be successful" [20].

On 11/23 September, according to a note on the manuscript, the third movement was finished. On 13/25 September, Tchaikovsky wrote to Balakirev: "I have carried out your wish. Manfred is finished, and the full score will soon be engraved... I have sat over Manfred, not rising from my seat, you might say, for almost four months (from the end of May until today). It was very difficult, but also very pleasant to work on, especially when, having begun with some labour, I became captivated. The symphony is written in accordance with your programme, in four movements. But I ask your forgiveness — I have not been able to keep to the keys and modulations you proposed, even though I wanted to do so. The symphony is written in the key of B minor. Only the scherzo is in the key you indicated[21]. This piece is very difficult, and requires an enormous orchestra, i.e. with a very large string section. As soon as the proofs of the symphony are ready, I shall send them to you" [22].

On the same day, he wrote to Modest Tchaikovsky: "I am finishing my symphony with a feverish haste, so that I can rid myself of this encumbrance before I move to my new home... Tomorrow we leave for Moscow with Panya and, unfortunately, at this rate I will still be finishing off my work" [23]. On 20 September/2 October, Tchaikovsky told him: "I still have not managed to finish Manfred. It still needs a few days more work"[24]. On the last page of the manuscript score of the finale is the date: "End of the symphony 22 Sept 1885 (O.S.). Maydanovo".

On 9/21 October, Tchaikovsky wrote to Emiliya Pavlovskaya: "I have finished the symphony, and did not pause even for an hour before starting on the opera [The Enchantress]" [25].

Arrangements

While orchestrating the symphony, Tchaikovsky simultaneously made his own arrangement for piano duet (4 hands). The fair copy of the arrangement is dated 3 September 1885 (O.S.). Concerned that this arrangement might prove too difficult, and contain mistakes, Tchaikovsky asked Aleksandra Hubert to look through it [26]. And so, there appeared a second version of the arrangement of the symphony, written by Aleksandra Hubert and containing numerous corrections and additions by Tchaikovsky. In November, the autograph of the arrangement was sent to Balakirev for him to look over [27]. Balakirev did not return the manuscript until March, attaching some additional pages containing his own notes. Unfortunately, these notes were misplaced, so that it is not possible to ascertain whether Tchaikovsky took them into account when the arrangement was published.

Performances

The symphony was performed for the first time on 11/23 March 1886 in Moscow, at the eleventh symphony concert of the Russian Musical Society (dedicated to the memory of Nikolay Rubinstein), conducted by Max Erdmannsdörfer [28].

Other notable early performances included:

  • Pavlovsk, 2/14 May 1886, conducted by Vojtěch Hlaváč
  • New York, Metropolitan Opera House, Philharmonic Society concert, 21 November/3 December 1886, conducted by Theodore Thomas
  • Saint Petersburg, 5th Russian Musical Society symphony concert, 27 December 1886/8 January 1887, conducted by Anton Rubinstein
  • London, Queen's Hall Promenade Concert, 16/28 September 1898, conducted by Henry Wood.

Critical reception

On 13/25 March 1886, soon after the premiere of the symphony, Tchaikovsky wrote to Nadezhda von Meck: "I am very pleased with myself. I think that this is my best symphonic work. It was performed excellently, but it seemed to me that the public had little concept of it and received it rather coolly, although at the end I was given an ovation" [29].

Tchaikovsky's attitude towards Manfred was ambivalent. Immediately after finishing the symphony he was very pleased with it. "I think that this is the best I have ever written", "It seems to me that this is the best of all my works", he wrote in letters to Anna Merkling on 9/21 December 1885 and to Nadezhda von Meck on 6/18 February 1886 [30]. But on 15/27 February 1886, we find a note in his diary: "It's remarkable that I now have an unhealthy aversion to my latest works: Manfred and the opera" [31]. His judgement of the symphony following its performance in March 1886 was favourable [32].

Continue readingShow less 2 more paragraphs

Later on, Tchaikovsky took a different view of Manfred: "I loathe it, apart from the first movement. The others are considerably worse, and the finale is very weak" [33]. Tchaikovsky's subsequent appraisal of Manfred was given in a letter to the Grand Duke Konstantin Konstantinovich of 21 September/3 October 1888: "As for Manfred, without any wish to make a mere show of modesty, I would like to say that it is an abominable piece, and that I loathe it deeply, with the exception of the first movement alone. However, I should tell Your Highness that shortly, with the agreement of my publisher, I shall destroy completely the remaining three movements, which musically are very poor (the Finale is particularly loathsome), and out of a large, impossibly long symphony, I shall make a Symphonische Dichtung. Then, I am sure, my Manfred will be capable of pleasing. Indeed, it must be so: the first movement I wrote with pleasure — the remaining ones are the result of exertion, from which, I remember, I felt for some time very ill" [34].

The composer's intention was not carried out, and the full score of the symphony remained in the form in which it was originally printed.

Publication

Manfred was originally published by Pyotr Jurgenson in Moscow.

The full score and piano duet arrangements were published in volumes 18 (1949) and volume 48 (1964) of Tchaikovsky's Complete Collected Works, edited by Yevgeny Makarov and Irina Iordan respectively.

Autographs

The composer's manuscript full score is now preserved in the Glinka National Museum Consortium of Musical Culture in Moscow.

The autograph of Tchaikovsky's arrangement for piano duet is held at the Klin House-Museum Archive (a1, No. 57). The manuscript of Aleksandra Hubert's piano duet arrangement, containing notes by Tchaikovsky, is now preserved in the Glinka National Museum Consortium of Musical Culture in Moscow.

Dedication

The Manfred symphony is dedicated to Mily Balakirev [35].

An early sketch for Astarte's theme in the first and fourth scenes was accompanied by the words 'Nessun maggior dolore' [‘No greater sorrow'] from Dante's Inferno, which Tchaikovsky had previously set to music. This sketch may once have been intended for a vocal work dating from 1884–85, but was later adapted to serve as Astarte's theme in the symphony.

The plainsong tune 'Dies irae' is quoted in the coda of the final movement (from bar 472).

Where he wrote it

May–October 1885: 9 stays in 4 places. Numbered in the order he reached each place, from where he came from to where he went next, traced from the place and date of his letters.

Dates are New Style (N.S.), the calendar used in the West. In Russia, on the Old Style calendar, the date was 12 days earlier.

Composed hereStayed while writingBefore and after

  1. Came fromMoscow20 April 1885 · 2 letters
  2. Maydanovo23 April – 3 May 1885 · 10 letters
  3. Moscow5 May 1885 · 1 letter
  4. Maydanovo8 May – 14 May 1885 · 12 letters
  5. Saint Petersburg19 May 1885 · 1 letter
  6. Maydanovo21 May 1885 · 3 letters
  7. Moscow30 May 1885 · 2 letters
  8. Smolensk1 June 1885 · 1 letter
  9. Moscow7 June – 12 June 1885 · 3 letters
  10. Maydanovo14 June – 29 October 1885 · 79 letters
  11. Went on toMoscow5 November 1885 · 2 letters

As he wrote it

What he said about this work in his letters, from the first mention to the last. Each passage is quoted word for word from the letter; open the letter to read the rest.

Before he began

  1. He has been fired up by the idea of my writing a grand symphony on the subject of "Manfred". I'll show you this eccentric fellow's curious letters.

    To Modest TchaikovskyKamenkaRead letter 2156

  2. I haven't embarked on "Manfred" in earnest yet, but I am thinking about it a lot.

    To Mily BalakirevParisRead letter 2611

While composing, 1885

  1. Unfortunately, he could not deliver the 1st act to me at the appointed time, and, in order not to waste time, back in April I began to make sketches for a long-planned programmatic symphony on the theme of Byron's "Manfred".

    To Nadezhda von MeckMaydanovoRead letter 2721

  2. After some hesitation, I have decided to write "Manfred", for I feel that until I fulfil the promise I unwisely made to Balakirev in the winter, I shall have no peace.

    To Sergey TaneyevMaydanovoRead letter 2722

  3. I am now writing a large symphony after the programme of Byron's "Manfred". I shall not be going anywhere for the whole summer, and look forward to seeing you at the start of August.

    To Nikolay KonradiMaydanovoRead letter 2729

  4. And so, in order not to let these three weeks be wasted in idleness, I set about the sketches for this symphony, and became so carried away, as frequently happens, that I could not stop.

    To Emiliya PavlovskayaMaydanovoRead letter 2741

  5. I am working on a very difficult, complex symphonic thing (on the subject of Byron's "Manfred"), which is possessed of such a tragic character that I have temporarily turned into some sort of Manfred.

    To Nadezhda von MeckMaydanovoRead letter 2745

  6. On the other hand, I think that my symphony will turn out to be the best of all my compositions in the symphonic genre. You must give me your word of honour that when it is played in Petersburg you will go and hear it.

    To Emiliya PavlovskayaMaydanovoRead letter 2747

All 73 letters

While composing, 1885

  1. To Nikolay TchaikovskyMaydanovoRead letter 2750

  2. To Félix MackarMaydanovoRead letter 2758

  3. My symphony has progressed so far that I hope to have it completely finished by the end of the month. I hope that my labour and efforts have not been in vain, and that I have indeed written something successful.

    To Nadezhda von MeckMaydanovoRead letter 2759

  4. I have finished my symphony, and, without tarrying a single hour, I set about composing the opera. Oh, what a fine fellow this Shpazhinsky is, and what a splendid colleague Fate has accorded to me in his person!

    To Emiliya PavlovskayaMaydanovoRead letter 2762a

  5. Manfred is finished, and the full score will soon be engraved. I think you will be a bit displeased about the speed with which I wrote it.

    To Mily BalakirevMaydanovoRead letter 2765

  6. All summer, under the impression of the gloomy subject of the symphony (Byron's "Manfred"), I was depressed and anxious.

    To Anna MerklingMaydanovoRead letter 2766

  7. I set about Manfred rather reluctantly and, if I may be frank, decided to write it precisely because I had promised you this — I made a firm promise, that I remember very clearly.

    To Mily BalakirevMaydanovoRead letter 2768

  8. Just imagine that I still haven't altogether finished "Manfred" yet. Amidst all the commotion in Moscow, I called on Pchelnikov, but didn't catch him.

    To Modest TchaikovskyMaydanovoRead letter 2771

  9. …time (in order to arrive in Maydanovo having completely dealt with the wearisome "Manfred"), then, unfortunately, on the 17th I could not be in Pleshcheyevo, where I wanted to celebrate your name day and that of my niece Vera.

    To Nadezhda von MeckMaydanovoRead letter 2772

  10. If you have better plans, then I shall be very upset, because there's much I want to discuss with you regarding "Manfred".

    To Aleksandra HubertMaydanovoRead letter 2773

  11. My "Manfred" will be played once or twice and then disappear for ages, and no one besides a handful of connoisseurs who attend symphony concerts will know it.

    To Nadezhda von MeckMaydanovoRead letter 2778

  12. I finally finished "Manfred" completely, and immediately set about composing "The Enchantress". Did I give you the 1st act libretto to read?

    To Modest TchaikovskyMaydanovoRead letter 2779

  13. The Huberts told me that you don't consider it possible to print "Manfred" this season. Is this true?

    To Pyotr JurgensonMaydanovoRead letter 2789

  14. However, I've also been working a great deal with Aleksandra Ivanovna Hubert, who's been giving me a lot of help with the piano arrangement of "Manfred".

    To Praskovya TchaikovskayaKharkovRead letter 2801

  15. Dear friend Mily Alekseyevich! If it hasn't been dispatched yet, the 4-handed arrangement of "Manfred" should be sent to your address very soon.

    To Mily BalakirevMaydanovoRead letter 2816

  16. At the moment I am correcting the proofs of a big symphonic work entitled Manfred.

    To Félix MackarMaydanovoRead letter 2819

  17. Since the programme of the "Manfred" Symphony was written by your hand, I think it will not be uninteresting for you to know that this symphony has already been written, and at the present time I am proof-reading the orchestral score.

    To Vladimir StasovMaydanovoRead letter 2822

  18. Dear Mily Alekseyevich! I am sending you today as a registered postal packet the manuscript of the first movement of Manfred.

    To Mily BalakirevMaydanovoRead letter 2824

  19. As for my other future works ("Manfred", for example), I do not yet know how I can transfer the rights to you without offending Jurgenson.

    To Félix MackarMaydanovoRead letter 2830

  20. I am currently proofreading my "Manfred". I think that this the best thing I have ever written.

    To Anna MerklingMaydanovoRead letter 2831

  21. This whole time I've been working diligently on the proofs of "Manfred". I'm starting to think more and more that this my best work.

    To Modest TchaikovskyMaydanovoRead letter 2832

  22. I'm so immersed in the proofs of "Manfred", and in such a rush with them, that my God I haven't found the time to visit Demyanovo.

    To Sergey TaneyevMaydanovoRead letter 2834

Afterwards

  1. I'm postponing my departure because I need to finish the proofs of "Manfred", which I haven't had the slightest chance to do here.

    To Modest TchaikovskyMoscowRead letter 2836

  2. I have spoken to Jurgenson regarding "Manfred" and the way in which we are to deal with such matters in future. He explained to me that he had already offered you the rights to Manfred, and that you had agreed to pay 1,000 francs for them.

    To Félix MackarMaydanovoRead letter 2839

  3. I wanted to go to Piter for the whole of the holidays, but the proofs of "Manfred" delayed me, and I'm staying here until the 28th.

    To Praskovya TchaikovskayaMaydanovoRead letter 2840

  4. Do you know that I've only now had the opportunity to think about the business of "Manfred", the fee and Mackar? I sat down to answer him and decided.

    To Pyotr JurgensonMaydanovoRead letter 2842

  5. To Pyotr JurgensonMaydanovoRead letter 2846

  6. To Pyotr JurgensonSaint PetersburgRead letter 2848

  7. "Manfred" isn't going to be played in Petersburg — this also offends me somewhat. I won't go into details about life in Petersburg: it's the usual mad commotion and crush.

    To Anatoly TchaikovskyMaydanovoRead letter 2853

  8. Overtures and symphonic poems: "Romeo": 1870 "The Tempest": 1873 "Francesca da Rimini": 1876 "Manfred": 1886

    To Félix MackarMaydanovoRead letter 2854

  9. "Manfred" is to be given on 11th March, the day of Nikolay Grigoryevich's death. You should definitely come.

    To Modest TchaikovskyMoscowRead letter 2871

  10. I suggested to Erdmannsdörfer that he should postpone the performance of "Manfred" until next year, and play the sinfonietta and something of Glazunov's this season.

    To Nikolay Rimsky-KorsakovMaydanovoRead letter 2873

  11. "Manfred" will be played on 11th March — the day that Nikolay Grigoryevich died. You should certainly come.

    To Modest TchaikovskyMaydanovoRead letter 2874

  12. "Manfred" is to be played on 11th March, and on the 12th I'm thinking of coming directly to you. The roads frighten me a little, but all being well they'll have cleared safely.

    To Praskovya TchaikovskayaMoscowRead letter 2876

  13. My "Manfred" will be given at the symphony concert on 11th March. It seems to me that this is the best of all my writings.

    To Nadezhda von MeckMoscowRead letter 2879

  14. Now, thank God, I'll be seeing you soon, because provided I'm alive and well, I'll certainly be leaving on 12 March, the day after the performance of my "Manfred".

    To Praskovya TchaikovskayaMaydanovoRead letter 2881

  15. As for 11th March, i.e. "Manfred", then you can come again (of course, with my financial assistance), especially since on the 12th I'm leaving for the Caucasus, and you would see me off.

    To Modest TchaikovskyMaydanovoRead letter 2885

  16. To Pyotr JurgensonMaydanovoRead letter 2887

  17. Besides, I definitely want to to be at "Manfred". Then you'll also see Maydanovo, i.e. on the 12th we'll come here and bring Laroche with us.

    To Modest TchaikovskyMaydanovoRead letter 2898

  18. And since rehearsals for Manfred start on Friday, then it follows that next week I'll be stuck in Moscow. Now the question arises, when should you leave?

    To Modest TchaikovskyMaydanovoRead letter 2903

  19. I should very much like you to come over tonight and to play through the 4-hand arrangement of the last two movements of "Manfred" with Balakirev's alterations.

    To Nikolay HubertMoscowRead letter 2908

  20. To Aleksandr OstrovskyMoscowRead letter 2909

  21. I shall visit you on Monday or Tuesday, in the morning or the afternoon, as the rehearsals for "Manfred" permit, and I shall bring you a ticket to the concert.

    To Yuliya ShpazhinskayaMoscowRead letter 2910

  22. Until we meet, most kind Yuliya Petrovna; I hope you will be at the concert today. "Manfred" is going very well.

    To Yuliya ShpazhinskayaMoscowRead letter 2911

  23. Secondly, I would like to share with you the impressions I had while hearing Manfred at rehearsals (at the concert I didn't hear it — that is, I was listening from a distance).

    To Mily BalakirevMaydanovoRead letter 2912

  24. Then the last 2 days were devoted to rehearsals for "Manfred", and attending the concert at which it was performed. I am pleased with myself; I think that this is my best symphonic work.

    To Nadezhda von MeckMaydanovoRead letter 2913

  25. Then, with the utmost precautions, I attended the rehearsals of "Manfred" for 3 days in a row, the performance of which took place on 11th March.

    To Praskovya TchaikovskayaMaydanovoRead letter 2914

  26. Manfred symphony, 1st movement.

    To Albert RepmanTiflisRead letter 2925

  27. 1) I ask you to send me 2 copies of "Manfred" and put them on my account.

    To Pyotr JurgensonTiflisRead letter 2926

  28. Request you send Ippolitov-Ivanov two copies of full score of Manfred.

    To Pyotr JurgensonTiflisRead letter 2935

  29. You praise "Manfred" too much. I am proud only of its first movement.

    To Mikhail Ippolitov-IvanovMaydanovoRead letter 3011

  30. I've now written him a letter, in which I have asked him in an earnest, friendly manner to play your symphony in the next concert, instead of the scheduled performance of "Manfred" (which had already been played last season, and can wait).

    To Eduard NápravníkMaydanovoRead letter 3133

  31. His answer will be interesting; I'll tell you immediately. I'll be very glad if "Manfred" waits until next season, and they put on something of yours instead.

    To Eduard NápravníkMaydanovoRead letter 3139

  32. Erdmannsdörfer wrote to me today that "Manfred" cannot be withdrawn from the programme, because rehearsals for it have already begun.

    To Eduard NápravníkMaydanovoRead letter 3140

  33. Laroche did not write a special article about "Manfred", but merely touched upon it in a large article about last year's musical season, published in the October book of "Russian Messenger".

    To Yuliya ShpazhinskayaMaydanovoRead letter 3174

  34. I would be very happy to send you the score and parts for Manfred, but not now—I shall do this much later, at the end of the season.

    To Julius LaubeFrolovskoyeRead letter 3587a

  35. As for Manfred, without any wish to make a mere show of modesty, I would like to say that it is an abominable piece, and that I loathe it deeply, with the exception of the first movement alone.

    To Grand Duke Konstantin KonstantinovichFrolovskoyeRead letter 3675

  36. In the capacity of an author whose works Erdmannsdörfer has often performed and, moreover, some excellently ("Manfred"), I should like to give him 100 rubles for a baton.

    To Pyotr JurgensonParisRead letter 3821

  37. There exist 2 arrangements for 2 pianos and 8 hands. 1) "Francesca", made by Lents. 2) "Manfred", made by Bryullov and Lents.

    To Pyotr JurgensonFlorenceRead letter 4066

  38. requests O. I. Jurgenson to send the score of Manfred.

    To Osip JurgensonSaint PetersburgRead letter 4263a

  39. But I hope to see you this evening. Bring the score of "Manfred".

    To Leopold AuerSaint PetersburgRead letter 4255

  40. Bruyllov and Lents are wondering about printing "Manfred" for 8 hands. Might you find this possible?

    To Pyotr JurgensonMaydanovoRead letter 4641

  41. The manuscript of Manfred for 8 hands can be found with Vladimir Aleksandrovich Bryullov. O. I. Jurgenson knows his address.

    To Pyotr JurgensonMaydanovoRead letter 4643

  42. (I would prefer to conduct the programme symphony Manfred, but as that is very difficult, I am afraid that I would not be able to manage it with just two rehearsals).

    To Francesco BergerParisRead letter 4844a

  43. We agonised over it terribly, so that it would be better and more convenient. I recalled the torments you and I had over "Manfred", if you remember?

    To Aleksandra HubertKlinRead letter 5014

Recordings

  1. Norbert Gembaczka, Russian National Orchestra

    Conductor: Mikhail Pletnev

    Manfred Symphony · 2013 · Pentatone

More recordings 3
  1. Rod Elms, London Symphony Orchestra

    Conductor: Yuri Simonov

    Tchaikovsky Edition · 1983 · Brilliant Classics

  2. London Philharmonic Orchestra

    Conductor: Vladimir Jurowski

    Manfred Symphony · 2004 · LPO

  3. NBC Symphony Orchestra

    Conductor: Arturo Toscanini

    Manfred Symphony / Romeo & Juliet · 1949 · RCA Victor Gold Seal

Scores and recordings on IMSLPAll recordings on MusicBrainzSearch YouTubeSearch SpotifySearch Apple Music

Recording details from MusicBrainz and Wikidata, both CC0. Audio from the Internet Archive is used under the licence shown with it.

Hear it live

Concert listings worldwide are on Bachtrack. Upcoming Tchaikovsky concerts on Bachtrack

The world around this work

Who he was writing to and what else was happening in his life, 1885.

Letters that discuss it 72

and 60 more

People around it

Whom he wrote to most in these years, and who appears in the letters about this work.

209 letters survive from these years. Letters of 1885

Meanwhile in his life

  • April 1885 At Maydanovo, he writes the symphony Manfred, suggested by Mily Balakirev.
  • 31 December 1884 / 12 January 1885 His niece Anna Davydova marries Nadezhda von Meck's son Nikolay.
  • 12/24 January 1885 Premiere of the Suite No. 3 in Saint Petersburg.
  • February 1885 He revises Vakula the Smith as a new opera with the title Cherevichki.
  • 14/26 February 1885 He rents a house in the village of Maydanovo, near Klin.
  • 22 February / 6 March 1885 Premiere of the Concert Fantasia in Moscow.
  • September 1885 He starts work on the opera The Enchantress.
  • 5/17 December 1885 Premiere of the Jurisprudence March and Jurists' Song at the 150th anniversary dinner of the Imperial School of Jurisprudence in Saint Petersburg. Tchaikovsky is absent.

Chronology 1885

In the world meanwhile

Places in this story

Saint Petersburg · Maydanovo · Moscow · Smolensk · Pavlovsk · New York · London · Klin · Davos

Letters about this work

Letters cited by Tchaikovsky Research. Those not yet on this site open there.

21582580259427182725273227332734276127762787

Listen next

Notes

  1. Letters from Mily Balakirev to Tchaikovsky of 28 September/10 October 1882 and 28 October/9 October 1882. ↩︎

  2. Letter 2158 to Mily Balakirev, 12/24 November 1882. ↩︎

  3. Letter 2156 to Modest Tchaikovsky, 8/20 November 1882. ↩︎

  4. Letter from Mily Balakirev to Tchaikovsky, 30 October/11 November 1884. ↩︎

  5. Tchaikovsky was travelling to Davos to see his dying friend Iosif Kotek. ↩︎

  6. Letter 2580 to Mily Balakirev, 31 October/12 November 1884. ↩︎

  7. See Letters 2594 and 2611 to Mily Balakirev, 17/29 November and 1/13 December 1884. ↩︎

  8. See Letter 2718 to Anna Merkling, 4/16 June 1885. ↩︎

  9. Letter 2718 to Anna Merkling, 4/16 June 1885. ↩︎

  10. Letter 2721 to Nadezhda von Meck, 13/25 June 1885. ↩︎

  11. Letter 2822 to Sergey Taneyev, 13/25 June 1885. ↩︎

  12. Letter 2768 to Mily Balakirev, now believed to have been written around 20 September/2 October–22 September/4 October 1885. ↩︎

  13. Tchaikovsky was busy correcting the proofs of the opera Cherevichki in June and July, as well as correcting his compositions for the church — see Letters 2725 and 2734 to Sofiya Jurgenson, 20 June/2 July and 8/20–9/21 July 1885. ↩︎

  14. Letter 2732 to Anna Merkling, 6/18 July 1885. ↩︎

  15. Letter 2733 to Sergey Taneyev, 8/20 July 1885. ↩︎

  16. Letter 2741 to Emiliya Pavlovskaya, 20 July/1 August 1885. ↩︎

  17. Letter 2745 to Nadezhda von Meck, 3/15 August 1885. ↩︎

  18. Letter 2750 to Nikolay Tchaikovsky, 19/31 August 1885. ↩︎

  19. Letter 2747 to Emiliya Pavlovskaya, 10/22 August 1885. ↩︎

  20. Letter 2759 to Nadezhda von Meck, 31 August/12 September 1885. ↩︎

  21. In both programmes, Mily Balakirev suggested that the Scherzo should be in the key of B-flat major. Tchaikovsky, evidently, was mistaken: the Scherzo of Manfred is set in B minor. ↩︎

  22. Letter 2765 to Mily Balakirev, 13/25 September 1885. ↩︎

  23. Letter 2761 to Modest Tchaikovsky, 3/15 September 1885. ↩︎

  24. Letter 2771 to Modest Tchaikovsky, 20 September/2 October 1885. See also Letter 2776 to Anna Merkling, 13/25 September 1885, and Letter 2772 to Nadezhda von Meck, 22 September/4 October 1885. ↩︎

  25. Letter 2787 to Emiliya Pavlovskaya, 9/21 October 1885. ↩︎

  26. See Letter 2768 to Mily Balakirev. 22 September/4 October 1885. ↩︎

  27. Letters from Mily Balakirev to Tchaikovsky, 16/28 November and 28 November/10 December 1885. ↩︎

  28. See Letter 2874 to Modest Tchaikovsky. 30 January/11 February 1886. ↩︎

  29. Letter 2913 to Nadezhda von Meck, 13/25 March 1886. ↩︎

  30. Letter 2831 to Anna Merkling, 9/21 December 1885, and Letter 2879 to Nadezhda von Meck, 6/18 February 1886. ↩︎

  31. The opera in question was The Enchantress. ↩︎

  32. See Letter 2912 to Mily Balakirev, and Letter 2913 to Nadezhda von Meck, both dated 13/25 March 1886. ↩︎

  33. Letter 3011 to Mikhail Ippolitov-Ivanov, 23 July/4 August 1886. ↩︎

  34. Letter 3675 to Grand Duke Konstantin Konstantinovich, 21 September/3 October 1888. ↩︎

  35. See Letter 2765 to Mily Balakirev, 13/25 September 1885. ↩︎

Sources

Licence: CC BY-NC-SA 4.0. Tchaikovsky Research (en.tchaikovsky-research.net).

Cite this page

Plain text

Manfred. Dear Tchaikovsky, https://deartchaikovsky.com/en/works/th28-manfred/. Last updated 18 November 2026.

Chicago

“Manfred.” Dear Tchaikovsky. Last updated 18 November 2026. https://deartchaikovsky.com/en/works/th28-manfred/.

BibTeX

@misc{deartchaikovsky-works-th28-manfred,
  title = {Manfred},
  howpublished = {Dear Tchaikovsky},
  url = {https://deartchaikovsky.com/en/works/th28-manfred/},
  date = {2026-11-18},
}