Tchaikovsky and Robert Schumann
Schumann was a favourite from his student years: in 1862 he and Herman Laroche played Schumann’s duets, and Anton Rubinstein set him the orchestration of the Symphonic Études. He translated Schumann’s rules for young musicians, published in 1868, and modelled his Children’s Album of 1878 on Kinderszenen. He loved Schumann’s Manfred so much that in 1882 he declined to write one of his own, though he found fault with the orchestration of Schumann’s symphonies.
In his letters
“Schumann's magnificent 3rd Symphony, which I love so much.”
“I love his Manfred extremely and am so used to merging in a single indivisible notion Byron's Manfred with Schumann's Manfred, that I cannot conceive how I might approach this subject in such a way as to elicit from it any music other than that which Schumann furnished it with.”