Symphony No. 4

Tchaikovsky's Symphony No. 4 in F minor, Op. 36, was begun in the spring of 1877 and completed in December the same year.

Genre
Symphonies
Key
F minor
Composed
1877
First performed
10/22 February 1878, Moscow
Catalogue
TH 27 · Op. 36 · ČW 24

Listen for

The passages people recognise, as simplified melody lines you can play. Underlined musical terms open the terms page.

The Fate fanfare

First movement, the opening bars (Andante sostenuto). Horns and bassoons in octaves, fortissimo.

Listen for the quick repeated notes that snap into a long one: a fanfare built from a single motif, played by horns and bassoons in octaves. Tchaikovsky told Nadezhda von Meck that this was Fate, the force that keeps happiness out of reach, which makes the symphony programme music. The same call breaks into the first movement again and again, and returns in the finale.

The introduction is the seed of the whole symphony, undoubtedly the main idea: This is Fate: this is that fateful force which prevents the impulse to happiness from attaining its goal.

Letter to Nadezhda von Meck, 17 February / 1 March 1878

Simplified melody line, not the full score. Source: Wikipedia (French), Symphonie no 4 de Tchaïkovski, checked against the full score, CC BY-SA 4.0.

The plucked scherzo

Third movement, Scherzo: Pizzicato ostinato (Allegro), bars 1–8. First violins; the strings pluck from the first bar to the last.

No bow touches a string in this movement: the players pluck, which is pizzicato. The title, Pizzicato ostinato, means stubbornly plucked, and the running eighth notes hardly stop; the woodwinds and then the brass get their own episodes in the middle. Tchaikovsky called the movement whimsical arabesques, the pictures that drift past after a little wine.

The third movement expresses no specific feeling. This is whimsical arabesques, vague images which can sweep past the imagination after drinking a little wine and feeling the first phases of intoxication.

Letter to Nadezhda von Meck, 17 February / 1 March 1878

Simplified melody line, not the full score. Source: Full score, public-domain scan on Wikimedia Commons (Scherzo, page 1), public domain.

“In the field a birch tree stood”

Fourth movement, Finale (Allegro con fuoco), bars 10–13. Flutes, clarinets and bassoons, in A minor.

Between the loud runs of the finale, the woodwinds play a Russian round-dance song first printed in the 1790s. This is quotation of a folk song: the tune is borrowed, and Tchaikovsky gives it new harmony and brings it back in other keys. It is the festive crowd from his letter about the symphony.

Go out among the people. See how they can enjoy themselves, surrendering themselves wholeheartedly to joyful feelings. Picture the festive merriment of ordinary people.

Letter to Nadezhda von Meck, 17 February / 1 March 1878

Simplified melody line, not the full score. Source: Full score, public-domain scan on Wikimedia Commons (Finale, pages 2–3; flute 1, an octave lower here), public domain.

The story

Tchaikovsky wrote most of the Fourth Symphony in 1877, the year his marriage fell apart, and finished the scoring abroad that winter. In a letter to Nadezhda von Meck he gave it a programme: the opening fanfare is Fate, the force that keeps us from being fully happy. He dedicated it to her without using her name; the title page says only "Dedicated to my best friend".

Subject

In letters to Nadezhda von Meck and Sergey Taneyev, Tchaikovsky disclosed more about the content of the Fourth Symphony. In a letter to Nadezhda von Meck of 17 February/1 March 1878, he set out a detailed programme for his Fourth Symphony: You asked me whether there is a definite programme to this symphony? Usually when this question is put to me about a symphonic work my answer is: none! Indeed, this is a difficult question to answer. How can one put into words the intangible sensations which one experiences when writing an instrumental work without a specific subject? This is a purely lyrical process. This is, fundamentally, an unburdening of the soul in music, with its essence distilled into sounds, in the same manner in which a lyrical poet expresses himself in verse. The only difference is that music has much more powerful means and a more subtle language with which to express thousands of different emotions and frames of mind. [...] In our symphony there is a programme, i.e. it is possible to express in words what it is trying to say, and to you, and only to you, I am able and willing to explain the meaning both of the whole and of the separate movements. Of course, I can do this only in general terms.

The introduction is the seed of the whole symphony, undoubtedly the main idea:

This is Fate: this is that fateful force which prevents the impulse to happiness from attaining its goal, which jealously ensures that peace and happiness shall not be complete and unclouded, which hangs above the head like the sword of Damocles, unwaveringly, constantly poisoning the soul. It is an invincible force that can never be overcome — merely endured, hopelessly.

The bleak and hopeless feelings grow stronger and intense. Is it not better to escape from reality and to immerse oneself in dreams:

Oh joy! Out of nowhere a sweet and gentle day-dream appears. Some blissful, radiant human image hurries by and beckons us away:

How wonderful! How distant the obsessive first theme of the allegro now sounds! Gradually the soul is enveloped by daydreams. Everything gloomy and joyless is forgotten. Here it is, here it is — happiness!

No! These were daydreams, and Fate wakes us from them:

And thus all life is an unbroken alternation of harsh reality with fleeting dreams and visions of happiness... No haven exists... Drift upon that sea until it engulfs and submerges you in its depths. That, roughly, is the programme of the first movement.

The second movement of the symphony expresses another aspect of sadness. This is that melancholy feeling which comes in the evening when, weary from one's toil, one sits alone with a book — but it falls from the hand. There come a whole host of memories. It is sad that so much is now in the past, albeit pleasant to recall one's youth. Both regretting the past, and yet not wishing to begin life over again. Life is wearisome. It is pleasant to rest and look around. Memories abound! Happy moments when the young blood boiled, and life was satisfying. There are also painful memories, irreconcilable losses. All this is now somewhere far distant. It is both sad, yet somehow sweet to be immersed in the past...

The third movement expresses no specific feeling. This is whimsical arabesques, vague images which can sweep past the imagination after drinking a little wine and feeling the first phases of intoxication. The spirit is neither cheerful, nor sad. Thinking about nothing in particular, giving free rein to the imagination, which somehow begins to paint strange pictures... Amid these memories there suddenly comes a picture of drunken peasants and a street song... Then, somewhere in the distance, a military procession passes. These are completely incoherent images which sweep through the head as one falls asleep. They have nothing in common with reality; they are strange, wild, and incoherent...

The fourth movement. If within yourself you find no reasons for joy, then look at others. Go out among the people. See how they can enjoy themselves, surrendering themselves wholeheartedly to joyful feelings. Picture the festive merriment of ordinary people. Hardly have you managed to forget yourself and to be carried away by the spectacle of the joys of others, than irrepressible fate appears again and reminds you of yourself. But others do not care about you, and they have not noticed that you are solitary and sad. O, how they are enjoying themselves! How happy they are that all their feelings are simple and straightforward. Reproach yourself, and do not say that everything in this world is sad. Joy is a simple but powerful force. Rejoice in the rejoicing of others. To live is still possible.

That, my dear friend, is all I can explain to you about the symphony. Of course, this is vague and incomplete. But an intrinsic quality of instrumental music is that it does not yield to detailed analysis [...] Just as I was about to put the letter in an envelope, I re-read it and was horrified at the incoherence and inadequacy of the programme I sent to you. This is the first time in my life that I have attempted to translate musical thoughts and images into words, and I could not manage to do this adequately. I was severely depressed last winter when writing the symphony, and it serves as a faithful echo of what I was experiencing. But it is known as an echo. How can it be translated into a clear and coherent succession of words? I do not know how to do that. I have already forgotten so much. They remain general recollections of the passions and mysterious feelings that I experienced" [38].

Instrumentation

The Symphony is scored for an orchestra comprising piccolo, 2 flutes, 2 oboes, 2 clarinets (in A, B-flat), 2 bassoons + 4 horns (in F), 2 trumpets (in F), 3 trombones, tuba + 3 timpani, triangle, cymbals, bass drum + violins I, violins II, violas, cellos, and double basses.

Movements and duration

There are four movements:

  1. Andante sostenuto — Moderato con anima (F minor, 424 bars)
  2. Andantino in modo di canzona (B-flat minor, 304 bars)
  3. Scherzo. Pizzicato ostinato. Allegro (F major, 414 bars)
  4. Finale. Allegro con fuoco (F major, 293 bars)
A complete performance lasts around 40 to 45 minutes.

Composition

The first references to the composition of the Fourth Symphony are encountered in letters from Tchaikovsky to Nadezhda von Meck dating from early May 1877. In a letter of 1/13 May, he wrote that he was now: "... engrossed in a symphony, which I began to write during the winter... Any other type of work would weigh heavily upon me at the moment — in other words the sort of work which requires a certain frame of mind... I find that now my nerves are frayed and irritable when I am deflected from the symphony, which progresses with some difficulty" [1].

By 3/15 May the first three movements had been written. "I have prepared the first three movements in sketch form, and have set about the finale", the composer wrote to Nadezhda von Meck, "but because lately I have had no inclination to work, I shall set it aside until the summer" [2]. Yet on 27 May/8 June, Tchaikovsky told her: "The symphony is finished, i.e. in outline. By the end of the summer it should be scored" [3].

Continue readingShow less 16 more paragraphs

In fact the instrumentation of the Symphony was not begun until August 1877. In May and June, the composer worked on his opera Yevgeny Onegin; then he travelled to Saint Petersburg and Kiev in connection with his wedding arrangements. He arrived at Kamenka on 30 July/12 August, but did not immediately start work there: "I would be lying if I said that I have returned to my normal state of mind. This is insufferable... and singularly disappointing. I have decided not to do any further work. Work frightens and oppresses me... Hopefully my urge to work will return" [4].

However, it was not long before Tchaikovsky began to orchestrate the Symphony [5], and on 12/24 August he could report: "Our symphony is progressing a little. I will take particular care when orchestrating the first movement — it is very long and complicated; yet it is also, in my opinion, the best movement. The remaining three are much simpler, and orchestrating them will be very enjoyable. The Scherzo employs a new orchestral effect, which I have designed myself" [6].

The instrumentation of the first movement was delayed. On 27 August/8 September, Tchaikovsky told his brother Anatoly that he was working on the piano score of the opera Yevgeny Onegin [7].

On 12/24 September, Tchaikovsky reported from Moscow to Nadezhda von Meck: "I have scored the first movement of the symphony" [8]. However, it is apparent from the composer's subsequent letters that the instrumentation of the first movement was still unfinished at this point.

On 24 September/6 October, for the sake of his health [following the end of his marriage], Tchaikovsky left Moscow for Saint Petersburg, and eventually abroad. In a letter of 16/28 October, he asked Pyotr Jurgenson to send on to Clarens the copy-book containing the sketches of the Symphony, which he had left behind in Moscow [9].

"I have done a little work, and now I can say with some certainty that our symphony will be finished by December at the latest...", he wrote to Nadezhda von Meck on 25 October/6 November 1877 [10].

The package with the sketches arrived in Switzerland when Tchaikovsky had already moved on to Rome, and the sketches did not reach him until 11/23 November. "You can imagine how anxious I was!", wrote Tchaikovsky to Nadezhda von Meck, "... if the symphony should have been lost, I would not have had the strength to write it all out again from memory!" [11].

Tchaikovsky did not take up the orchestration straight away, presumably because he did not want to interrupt the work he had already started on the opera Yevgeny Onegin [12].

From December onwards, Tchaikovsky worked on the instrumentation of the Symphony almost without interruption. From his surviving letters we can follow the course of work in detail:

  • 2/14 December: "Tomorrow I shall throw myself into the symphony..." [13].
  • 3/15 December: "... in the morning set about my symphony" [14].
  • 4/16 December: "I sat, immersed in the instrumentation of the symphony..." [15]. "This is the second day that I have worked on my symphony, and I am working very assiduously" [16].
  • 5/17 December: The instrumentation of the symphony "... comes to me with great difficulty. I wrote from morning to dinner time, until in the evening I was so tired that I could do no more" [17]. "... I have worked diligently on my symphony all day" [18].
  • 6/18 December: "The first movement is almost ready. I can say with confidence that this is my best composition" [19]. "I'm very satisfied with my symphony, which is undoubtedly the best that I've written, but it's not coming to me without hard work, particularly the first movement" [20].
  • 7/19 December: "I'm probably near the end of the symphony, on which I've worked with great vigour" [21].
  • 9/21 December: "Not only am I occupying myself assiduously with scoring our symphony, I am utterly absorbed in this work. None of my previous orchestral works ever cost me such labour, yet I have never felt such a love for one of my own pieces. I found that I was pleasantly surprised by this work. At first I wrote largely for the sake of completing the symphony, knowing how difficult this task would eventually be. But little by little it captured my enthusiasm, and now my difficulties have fallen away... perhaps I am mistaken, but I think that this symphony is something out of the ordinary, and that it is the best thing I have done so far... Now I... can wholly devote myself to work in the knowledge that I am bringing forth something which, in my opinion, shall not be forgotten..." [22].
  • 10/22 December: "The first movement of the symphony is coming to an end. Today I worked extremely hard, and I'm very tired" [23].
  • 11/23 December: "Today I finished the most difficult movement of the symphony — the first" [24]. On the fair copy of the manuscript full score of the first movement is the note: "Venice 23(11) December 1877".
  • 12/24 December: "Today I set about the second half of the symphony's second movement. The work becomes easier with each hour that passes. I hope that, in spite of the interruption, the whole thing will be finished before our New Year" [25]. "When I wrote the opera [Yevgeny Onegin], I did not experience the same feeling as with the symphony. There I took a chance: perhaps it will do, or maybe nothing will come of it. But while writing the symphony I'm fully aware that it is a composition out of the ordinary, and far more perfect in form than anything I've written previously" [26].
The date on the manuscript full score of the second movement indicates that the instrumentation was completed on 13/25 December 1877.
  • 15/27 December: "The symphony is absorbing me so much, that I haven't the strength to tear myself away from it" [27]. "Finished the Scherzo. Very tired" [28]. The date on the manuscript of the third movement reads: "27/15 Dec 1877. Venezia".
  • 16/28 December: "There can be no question that in these two weeks my state of health, physically and mentally, has been excellent. A not inconsiderable factor in this has been my symphony, the work on which has filled me with enthusiasm... At the moment three movements are ready; I do not know how long I shall be busy with the remainder — but it seems to me that these three movements represent the crowning glory of all my musical achievements" [29].
  • 20 December 1877/1 January 1878: "In this symphony I have succeeded in writing something good — tomorrow I shall be reconciled to all former and future misfortunes" [30].

Work on the Symphony was interrupted for a few days by negotiations concerning Tchaikovsky's appointment to a delegation at the Paris International Exhibition ("I was preparing to start on the finale of the symphony today...") [31]. Tchaikovsky declined to go on this tour: "I cannot see people, I need to isolate myself from all the hustle and bustle [...] Peace, peace, peace and work — these are the only two things that I need now", he wrote to Nikolay Rubinstein, who had proposed his name for the delegation [32].

On 24 December/5 January, Tchaikovsky resumed the instrumentation of the Symphony: "This morning I set about my symphony, and worked all day; this is the reason that I am so tired...", he wrote to Anatoly Tchaikovsky the same day [33].

On 26 December/7 January, the composer reported: "Yesterday and today I sat, without rising, and today I have finished my dear symphony" [34]. This statement is corroborated by a note after the fourth movement of the manuscript score: "San Remo 7 Jan 1878 (26 Dec 1877)".

A few more days were devoted to "putting the final touches to the full score, which I shall take with me, so that in Milan I might obtain a metronome and insert the correct tempi". On 29 December/10 January, Tchaikovsky sent the full score to Moscow [35].

On finishing the Symphony, the composer wrote: "It seems to me that this is my best work. Of my two latest creations, i.e. the opera and the symphony, I favour the latter" [36]. "What lies in store for this symphony? Will it survive long after its author has disappeared from the face of the earth, or straight away plunge into the depths of oblivion? I only know that at this moment I... am blind to any shortcomings in my new offspring. Yet I am sure that, as regards texture and form, it represents a step forward in my development..." [37].

Performances

The Fourth Symphony was performed for the first time in Moscow at the tenth concert of the Russian Musical Society on 10/22 February 1878, conducted by Nikolay Rubinstein, where it had great success. On 25 November/7 December the same year, the work was performed in Saint Petersburg at the fifth symphony concert of the Russian Musical Society, conducted by Eduard Nápravník.

Other notable early performances included:

  • Paris, 15th Châtelet concert, 13/25 January 1880, conducted by Édouard Colonne
  • Pavlovsk, symphony concert, 29 August/10 September 1888, conducted by Julius Laube
  • Dresden, 5th Philharmonic Society concert, 8/20 February 1889, conducted by Tchaikovsky
  • New York, Metropolitan Opera House, Symphony Society concert, 20 January/1 February 1890, conducted by Walter Damrosch
  • Kiev, 2nd Russian Musical Society symphony concert, 5/17 December 1890, conducted by Aleksandr Vinogradsky
  • London, Saint James's Hall, Philharmonic Society concert, 20 May/1 June 1893, conducted by Tchaikovsky
  • Amsterdam, Concertgebouw, subscription concert, 28 October/9 November 1893, conducted by Willem Kes
  • Prague, National Theatre, 22 January/3 February 1896, conducted by Vasily Safonov
  • Amsterdam, Concertgebouw, subscription concert, 15/27 February 1896, conducted by Willem Mengelberg

Critical reception

Following the Saint Petersburg premiere, Modest Tchaikovsky wrote about the impression the Symphony had made on the public: If ever a symphonic work produced a furore after its performance, then it was your symphony. After the first movement the applause was moderate — how should I say? — something like what is usually heard after the first movement of a Beethoven or Schumann symphony; after the second movement there was considerably more applause — such that Nápravník was even obliged to take a bow; after the Scherzo — a fff clamour, stamping and cries of "bis". Nápravník bowed once more... and the noise only intensified, until the conductor raised his baton. Then everyone fell silent until only your pizzicato could be heard... After this, more cries, calls, bows by Nápravník, and so on. The end of the Finale was greeted with unanimous applause, calls and stamping of feet... The performance was very lively, but in the last movement... breathtaking [39].

Responding to Sergey Taneyev, who wrote that "The trumpet fanfares which constitute the introduction, and which subsequently appear from time to time, the changes of tempo in the second subject — all these make one think that this is programme music..." [40], Tchaikovsky replied: As to your remark that my symphony is programmatic, then I am in complete agreement. I just do not understand why you consider this to be a defect. It is the opposite that I fear — i.e. I should not wish symphonic works to flow from my pen that express nothing, and which consist of empty playing with chords, rhythms and modulations. My symphony is, of course, programmatic, but the programme is such that it is impossible to formulate in words. Such a thing would provoke ridicule and laughter. But is this not what a symphony, that is, the most lyrical of all musical forms, ought to be? Ought it not to express everything for which there are no words, but which gushes forth from the soul and cries out to be expressed? However, I must confess to you: in my naivety I imagined that the idea of the symphony was very clear, that in general outline its sense could be understood even without a programme. Please do not think that I am trying to plume myself in front of you with my depth of feelings and grandeur of thoughts that are not susceptible of verbal expression. I was not even seeking to express a new idea. In essence my symphony is an imitation of Beethoven's Fifth, that is, I was imitating not his musical thoughts, but the fundamental idea. [...] Furthermore, I'll add that there is not a note in this symphony (that is, in mine) which I did not feel deeply, and which did not serve as an echo of sincere impulses within my soul. A possible exception is the middle of the first movement, in which there are contrivances, seams, glued-together bits — in a word, artificiality [41].

All his life, Tchaikovsky retained a love for this symphony. At the end of 1878 he wrote: "I adore terribly this child of mine; it is one of only a few works with which I have not experienced disappointment" [42]. Ten years later, when referring to the symphony, he wrote "it turns out that not only have I not cooled towards it, as I have cooled towards the greater part of my compositions, but on the contrary, I am filled with warm and sympathetic feelings towards it. I don't know what the future may bring, but presently it seems to me that this is my best symphonic work" [43].

Publication

Tchaikovsky was very anxious that the Symphony should be published in the best possible way [44]. When dispatching the full score to Moscow, Tchaikovsky asked Jurgenson to entrust the piano duet arrangement to Sergey Taneyev or Karl Klindworth [45]. The next day he approached Taneyev with the same request, and the latter readily agreed [46]. However, this work was delayed until June 1878 because of a projected performance in Saint Petersburg, and Nikolay Rubinstein's intention to perform the Scherzo from the Symphony in Paris [47]. On 6/18 November 1878, Tchaikovsky wrote to Nadezhda von Meck: "Our symphony is being printed" [48]. However, it was not until June 1879 that he checked the proofs of the full score and piano arrangement.

The symphony was published by Pyotr Jurgenson in Moscow, with Daniel Rahter in Hamburg acting as his European agent.

Rahter also engraved his own versions of some of Jurgenson's editions, as well as commissioning two arrangements that were published under his own imprint:

The full score of the Symphony was published in volume 16Б of Tchaikovsky's Complete Collected Works, edited by Pavel Berlinsky (1949).

Autographs

Tchaikovsky's manuscript score is now preserved in the Glinka National Museum Consortium of Musical Culture in Moscow.

Dedication

The Symphony No. 4 is dedicated (clandestinely) to Nadezhda von Meck — on the title page is the inscription: "Dedicated to my best friend" [52].

The main theme of the Finale (movt. IV) is a variant of the folk tune 'In the Field a Birch-Tree Stood' (Во поле береза стояла), which Tchaikovsky had harmonized as No. 9 in Set 2 of Mariya Mamontova's collection of Children's Songs on Russian and Ukrainian Tunes (1877).

Where he wrote it

January–December 1877: 21 stays in 15 places. Numbered in the order he reached each place, from where he came from to where he went next, traced from the place and date of his letters.

Dates are New Style (N.S.), the calendar used in the West. In Russia, on the Old Style calendar, the date was 12 days earlier.

  1. Moscow4 January – 8 June 1877 · 41 letters
  2. Glebovo21 June – 5 July 1877 · 4 letters
  3. Moscow15 July – 18 July 1877 · 5 letters
  4. Saint Petersburg20 July – 25 July 1877 · 6 letters
  5. Moscow27 July – 7 August 1877 · 8 letters
  6. Kiev9 August 1877 · 1 letter
  7. Kamenka14 August – 18 September 1877 · 7 letters
  8. Kiev21 September 1877 · 1 letter
  9. Moscow24 September – 6 October 1877 · 6 letters
  10. Saint Petersburg13 October 1877 · 3 letters
  11. Berlin17 October 1877 · 3 letters
10 more stays
  1. Geneva21 October 1877 · 2 letters
  2. Clarens23 October – 12 November 1877 · 21 letters
  3. Paris13 November – 14 November 1877 · 3 letters
  4. Florence18 November 1877 · 1 letter
  5. Rome19 November – 22 November 1877 · 5 letters
  6. Venice23 November – 30 November 1877 · 7 letters
  7. Vienna1 December – 13 December 1877 · 18 letters
  8. Venice14 December – 27 December 1877 · 25 letters
  9. Milan28 December 1877 · 1 letter
  10. San Remo31 December 1877 · 1 letter

As he wrote it

What he said about this work in his letters, from the first mention to the last. Each passage is quoted word for word from the letter; open the letter to read the rest.

While composing, 1877

  1. One day soon, my man Aleksey will be bringing you a bound notebook, containing the rough draft of my symphony. Kindly forward it to me here.

    To Pyotr JurgensonClarensRead letter 620

  2. I am unlikely to be able to orchestrate the whole opera in time, particularly since I am terribly drawn to the symphony, which I consider to be the best thing I have written thus far.

    To Nikolay RubinsteinClarensRead letter 623

  3. Today my brother and I walked very far into the mountains and enjoyed ourselves with all our heart. Then I shall sit down to my opera again, as well as to my symphony, which I wrote in sketch form last winter

    To Karl AlbrechtClarensRead letter 624

  4. As soon as I finish the first scene of the 2nd act and send it to you, I shall enthusiastically set about the symphony, which I beg you to reserve for one of the last concerts.

    To Nikolay RubinsteinRomeRead letter 642

  5. …letters in general, 2) a lettre chargée from Madame Meck in particular, and 3) my symphony, which was supposed to arrive in Clarens the day after my departure, and had been sent on to me here.

    To Modest TchaikovskyRomeRead letter 643

  6. When I return from Vienna, I shall set to work on the symphony, our symphony, and will not rise until I have finished it.

    To Nadezhda von MeckVeniceRead letter 650

  7. I daresay I'll miss you terribly for some time, but little by little I'll become used to it, and once I'm immersed in the symphony, I shall be at peace.

    To Anatoly TchaikovskyViennaRead letter 666

  8. Yet as regards to the symphony which I am now orchestrating, I implore Nikolay Grigoryevich to leave a slot for it at the end of the season.

    To Karl AlbrechtVeniceRead letter 671

All 69 letters

While composing, 1877

  1. I slept very well, and in the morning I set about the symphony. After lunch I went with Alyosha to the Doge's Palace and strolled around the streets.

    To Anatoly TchaikovskyVeniceRead letter 672

  2. I have now taken up the symphony and shall send it to you next month. For God's sake, save a place for it in the 9th or 10th concert.

    To Nikolay RubinsteinVeniceRead letter 675

  3. I am now working very hard on the symphony. The first movement is almost ready.

    To Nadezhda von MeckVeniceRead letter 679

  4. I will probably finish off the symphony — a task that I have embarked upon with great energy — and then head for somewhere in Switzerland.

    To Sergey TaneyevVeniceRead letter 681

  5. Naturally, I owe all this to the symphony, but it was only thanks to the monotony of Venetian life and the lack of any entertainment that I was able to occupy myself so persistently and so diligently.

    To Anatoly TchaikovskyVeniceRead letter 686

Afterwards

  1. …was able to finish completely that which was still unfinished in the score of the symphony, which I had purposefully taken with me in order to obtain a metronome in Milan, and to set the tempi precisely.

    To Nadezhda von MeckGenoaRead letter 711

  2. Enough of "Onegin". I shall talk to you about my new work, the Fourth Symphony, which by now should have arrived in Moscow.

    To Sergey TaneyevSan RemoRead letter 716

  3. I am referring to my symphony. Do love it, for God's sake, as my mind cannot be at rest until you have praised me.

    To Karl AlbrechtSan RemoRead letter 720

  4. To Karl AlbrechtSan RemoRead letter 731

  5. I am profoundly saddened, offended and surprised by the incomprehensible silence from all my Moscow friends regarding the symphony.

    To Nadezhda von MeckClarensRead letter 775

  6. I very much liked Lalo's Symphonie espagnole. After tea we played my 4th symphony, which Modya had never heard before.

    To Anatoly TchaikovskyClarensRead letter 776

  7. I have yet to hear anything from Moscow about the symphony — not a single word of sympathy or praise. Jurgenson writes to me that Rubinstein will be playing my concerto.

    To Nadezhda von MeckClarensRead letter 780

  8. I was very upset that none of you wrote me a single word about the symphony. Fool that I am, I had imagined that you, Rubinstein, Kashkin and Hubert, with the first impression still fresh in your minds, would at once write me something.

    To Karl AlbrechtClarensRead letter 781

  9. You were wrong to suppose that in your comments on my Fourth Symphony there might be anything unduly sharp. This is simply your frank opinion, and I am very grateful to you for sharing it with me.

    To Sergey TaneyevClarensRead letter 799

  10. Thus, for example, in our symphony, the first movement is written with very deliberate deviations. The second theme, which should be in a related and, moreover, major key, I have in a distant minor.

    To Nadezhda von MeckKamenkaRead letter 862

  11. The following of my works will be performed: the Piano Concerto, "The Tempest", "Francesca", and two movements from our symphony.

    To Nadezhda von MeckVerbovkaRead letter 866

  12. To Sergey TaneyevKamenkaRead letter 869a

  13. Either I shall put the same on the title page as on the symphony — or I shall put nothing, i.e. this dedication shall only be known to the two of us.

    To Nadezhda von MeckVerbovkaRead letter 901

  14. Our symphony is being printed. I feel awfully embarrassed before you that is still not ready.

    To Nadezhda von MeckKamenkaRead letter 959

  15. I hope that you have already received the scherzo of the 4th symphony.

    To Eduard NápravníkKamenkaRead letter 962

  16. Incidentally, please don't forget to dedicate the 6 romances to Anatoly, the 12 pieces to Modest, and the symphony to my best friend.

    To Pyotr JurgensonKamenkaRead letter 964

  17. To Nadezhda von MeckFlorenceRead letter 983

  18. I did not know that the symphony had now been scheduled for performance. His report of success is thoroughly reliable.

    To Nadezhda von MeckFlorenceRead letter 985

  19. Having learned from the bitter experience of the symphony, this time I want the piano reduction to be ready at the same time as the score, so that by the time the suite is performed it will already be in print.

    To Nadezhda von MeckFlorenceRead letter 992

  20. This is convenient for me, for Jurgenson, and for the public. Do you know, for example, why the publication of our symphony took so long?

    To Nadezhda von MeckKamenkaRead letter 1154

  21. By the way, why is he proofreading the 4th symphony and not Taneyev? In any case, before it goes to print, send it to me for a final review!

    To Pyotr JurgensonKamenkaRead letter 1182

  22. The other day I was working on the proofs of our symphony — two years after it was composed! I very much like the arrangement, made by Taneyev.

    To Nadezhda von MeckKamenkaRead letter 1197

  23. It was only from your letter that I learned that our symphony had finally been published. The absent-minded Jurgenson had forgotten to tell me.

    To Nadezhda von MeckSaint PetersburgRead letter 1297

  24. But when replying to your proposal regarding the symphony, I completely forgot that neither the score nor the parts have appeared in print.

    To Nadezhda von MeckKamenkaRead letter 1307

  25. I wrote this music with love, with pleasure, just like "Onegin", the 4th Symphony and 2nd quartet.

    To Nadezhda von MeckKamenkaRead letter 1311

  26. But then there are individual human personalities close to me (for example, that best friend to whom my 4th Symphony is dedicated), who cause me to love that person and marvel at the perfection that their moral beauty can achieve.

    To Nadezhda von MeckKamenkaRead letter 1313

  27. I know in advance that our symphony will be much criticised. But it will arouse interest, and nothing more is needed now.

    To Nadezhda von MeckParisRead letter 1341

  28. To Nadezhda von MeckParisRead letter 1343

  29. You probably know that Colonne, at Madame Meck's request, will be playing my 4th Symphony. Please, golubchik, keep this between us so that no-one knows that this symphony was imposed on him at a price.

    To Pyotr JurgensonParisRead letter 1345

  30. I should like it very much if you were satisfied with the arrangement for 4 hands, although I forewarn you that it is not done as masterfully as the arrangement of the 4th symphony.

    To Nadezhda von MeckRomeRead letter 1385

  31. …that the suite is a mere plaything when compared to Francesca, or even to the 4th Symphony, with regard to which it did not even occur to Nikolay Grigoryevich to complain about any particular difficulties.

    To Sergey TaneyevRomeRead letter 1396

  32. Two days ago, I received a telegram from Colonne informing me that my 4th Symphony was a success in Paris, especially the Andante and Scherzo.

    To Anatoly TchaikovskyRomeRead letter 1407

  33. I need not say how overjoyed I am that you liked the symphony. I should be so upset if your attempts to arrange a performance in Paris were unsuccessful!

    To Nadezhda von MeckRomeRead letter 1408

  34. …the Society's directorate to select a number from my following compositions: 1) 4th Symphony (F minor) 2) 2nd Symphony (C minor) in corrected form. 3) "Italian Capriccio" for orchestra (a new composition) 4) Violin Concerto, which has not…

    To Jan SeifertKamenkaRead letter 1496

  35. I wrote that I would be very glad for him to play the 4th Symphony, the Suite, "The Tempest" and the "Italian Capriccio".

    To Pyotr JurgensonKamenkaRead letter 1556

  36. "Danish Overture" for 4 hands. Fourth Symphony for 4 hands. ⎫ ⎬ works by ⎭Tchaikovsky } Put all this on my account.

    To Pyotr JurgensonKamenkaRead letter 1581

  37. 1) a) Suite for 4 hands, b) 4th Symphony for 4 hands; c) "Francesca" for 4 hands, d) "The Tempest" for 4 hands and e) 1st Quartet for 4 hands, to be sent abroad to the following address: Oberviller, par Sarreburg, Alsace-Lorraine, à Madame…

    To Pyotr JurgensonKamenkaRead letter 1593

  38. For what reason did you send me the full score of the 4th symphony? Did I proofread it or not?

    To Pyotr JurgensonKamenkaRead letter 1600

  39. Colonne was more favourably disposed towards me a few years ago: he played my 4th Symphony twice, he played my "Tempest".

    To Félix MackarMaydanovoRead letter 2854

  40. It is absolutely essential that I review the parts of the 4th symphony. The parts of the 1st can probably be done without me.

    To Pyotr JurgensonTiflisRead letter 3545

  41. Recently, in connection with the printing of the orchestral parts of my (our) 4th symphony, I renewed my acquaintance with her — as I had already begun to forget her somewhat.

    To Nadezhda von MeckFrolovskoyeRead letter 3572

  42. It is extremely agreeable for me that you approve of my 4th Symphony, because this is one of my very favourite offspring — one of those which from beginning to end were written under the effect of real inspiration, with love and sincere…

    To Grand Duke Konstantin KonstantinovichFrolovskoyeRead letter 3685

  43. Last night I looked through the 4th symphony — ours! How different this is, how much loftier and superior!

    To Nadezhda von MeckFrolovskoyeRead letter 3738

  44. And I am absolutely convinced that our symphony is infinitely better than the last one.

    To Nadezhda von MeckFrolovskoyeRead letter 3748

  45. Please make Monsieur Wüllner aware that I should like the Cologne public to hear my 4th symphony, but if it should happen that he were to absolutely insist on the Suite No. 3, then I could not ask for anything better than to conduct that…

    To Hermann WolffFrolovskoyeRead letter 3754a

  46. The Dresden orchestra turned out to be very mediocre, and it was very difficult for me there, especially since the parts of the 4th symphony, which I played, turned out to have a lot of mistakes, as always with Jurgenson.

    To Aleksandr GlazunovBerlinRead letter 3794

  47. I played my Fourth Symphony there (which you heard in Pavlovsk last summer), and, despite the mediocre performance, it caused a sensation.

    To Grand Duke Konstantin KonstantinovichLeipzigRead letter 3802

  48. It turns out that my 4th symphony produced a sensation in Dresden. I'm sending you Hartmanns second article about it.

    To Pyotr JurgensonLeipzigRead letter 3804

  49. If we are both successful, then in the next season let us come and do my 5th or 4th symphony, or play my 2nd concerto.

    To Francesco BergerGenevaRead letter 3808a

  50. …for your notification about how to fill out the existing concert programme (the 4th symphony and my two "Voyevodas"), which virtuoso I'll be dealing with, and when the concert is to take place.

    To Pavel PeterssenMaydanovoRead letter 4479

  51. To Francesco BergerSaint PetersburgRead letter 4812c

  52. Now I have read your letter again, and see that you were calling on me to listen to the 4th symphony on this date. Alas!

    To Vasily SafonovSaint PetersburgRead letter 4825

  53. So at the concert on 1 June I shall conduct my 4th Symphony. (I would prefer to conduct the programme symphony Manfred, but as that is very difficult, I am afraid that I would not be able to manage it with just two rehearsals).

    To Francesco BergerParisRead letter 4844a

  54. On the third day here I had enormous success with my Symphony No. 4. But life here is like hell—there is no single peaceful moment and sometimes I'm losing my mind.

    To Aleksandr ZilotiLondonRead letter 4939

  55. I've been here a whole week. The Philharmonic Society concert has taken place; I had an enormous success with the 4th Symphony.

    To Pyotr JurgensonLondonRead letter 4942

  56. I had a huge success in London with my 4th symphony which, as they say, will never be forgotten. No less successful was the Cambridge concert, in which we all (i.e. each of the doctors) conducted our own works.

    To Vladimir NápravníkParisRead letter 4949

Recordings

  1. Willem Mengelberg

    TCHAIKOVSKY: Symphony No. 4 · 1929

More recordings 4
  1. Berliner Philharmoniker

    Conductor: Herbert von Karajan

    Symphonies 4, 5 & 6 “Pathétique” · 1971 · EMI Classics

  2. Oslo‐Filharmonien

    Conductor: Mariss Jansons

    Symphony 4 in F minor, op. 36 · 1984 · Chandos

  3. Berliner Philharmoniker

    Conductor: Lorin Maazel

    Complete Early Berlin Philharmonic Recordings 1957 - 1962 · 1960 · Deutsche Grammophon

  4. Mariinsky Orchestra

    Conductor: Valery Gergiev

    Symphony No. 4 / The Nutcracker · 2015 · Mariinsky

Scores and recordings on IMSLPAll recordings on MusicBrainzSearch YouTubeSearch SpotifySearch Apple Music

Recording details from MusicBrainz and Wikidata, both CC0. Audio from the Internet Archive is used under the licence shown with it.

Hear it live

Concert listings worldwide are on Bachtrack. Upcoming Tchaikovsky concerts on Bachtrack

The world around this work

Who he was writing to and what else was happening in his life, 1877.

Letters that discuss it 69

and 57 more

People around it

Whom he wrote to most in these years, and who appears in the letters about this work.

169 letters survive from these years. Letters of 1877

Meanwhile in his life

  • March 1877 He makes sketches for his Symphony No. 4.
  • 1877 The couple spend their honeymoon in Saint Petersburg.
  • January 1877 He strikes up a close friendship with the violinist Iosif Kotek.
  • 13/25 February 1877 He nervously conducts his Slavonic March at the Bolshoi Theatre in Moscow.
  • 25 February / 9 March 1877 Premiere of Francesca da Rimini in Moscow.
  • 26 March / 7 April 1877 Antonina Milyukova writes her first letter to Tchaikovsky.
  • May 1877 He begins to write the opera Yevgeny Onegin.
  • 20 May / 1 June 1877 He meets Antonina Milyukova for the first time in Moscow.
  • 23 May / 4 June 1877 He proposes marriage to Antonina Milyukova.

Chronology 1877

In the world meanwhile

Places in this story

Saint Petersburg · Kiev · Kamenka · Moscow · Clarens · Rome · Venice · Paris · San Remo · Milan · Pavlovsk · Dresden · New York · London · Prague · Hamburg · Klin

Letters about this work

Letters cited by Tchaikovsky Research. Those not yet on this site open there.

5545575695745935945955966016216266446706736766776786806836846896906916926967007027087097137247257638001632

Listen next

Notes

  1. Letter 554 to Nadezhda von Meck, 1/13 May 1877. ↩︎

  2. Letter 557 to Nadezhda von Meck, 3/15 May 1877. ↩︎

  3. Letter 569 to Nadezhda von Meck, 27 May/8 June 1877. ↩︎

  4. Letter 593 to Nadezhda von Meck, 2/14 August 1877. ↩︎

  5. See Letter 594 to Nadezhda von Meck, 11/23 August 1877. ↩︎

  6. Letter 595 to Nadezhda von Meck, 12/24 August 1877. ↩︎

  7. See Letter 596 to Anatoly Tchaikovsky, 27 August/8 September 1877. ↩︎

  8. Letter 601 to Nadezhda von Meck, 12/24 September 1877. ↩︎

  9. Letter 620 to Pyotr Jurgenson, 25 October/6 November 1877. ↩︎

  10. Letter 626 to Nadezhda von Meck, 25 October/6 November 1877. ↩︎

  11. Letter 644 to Nadezhda von Meck, 11/23 November 1877. ↩︎

  12. See Letter 621 to Modest Tchaikovsky, 17/29 October 1877, and Letter 1632 to Pyotr Jurgenson, 28 October/9 November 1877. ↩︎

  13. Letter 670 to Anatoly Tchaikovsky, 2/14–3/15 December 1877. ↩︎

  14. Letter 670 to Anatoly Tchaikovsky, 2/14–3/15 December 1877. ↩︎

  15. Letter 676 to Modest Tchaikovsky, 4/16 December 1877. ↩︎

  16. Letter 673 to Nadezhda von Meck, 4/16 December 1877. ↩︎

  17. Letter 677 to Pyotr Jurgenson, 5/17 December 1877. ↩︎

  18. Letter 678 to Anatoly Tchaikovsky, 5/17–7/19 December 1877. ↩︎

  19. Letter 679 to Nadezhda von Meck, 6/18 December 1877. ↩︎

  20. Letter 680 to Modest Tchaikovsky, 6/18 December 1877. ↩︎

  21. Letter 681 to Sergey Taneyev, 7/19 December 1877. ↩︎

  22. Letter 684 to Nadezhda von Meck, 9/21 December 1877. ↩︎

  23. Letter 683 to Anatoly Tchaikovsky, 8/20–10/22 December 1877. ↩︎

  24. Letter 686 to Anatoly Tchaikovsky, 11/23–14/26 December 1877. ↩︎

  25. Letter 689 to Nadezhda von Meck, 12/24 December 1877. ↩︎

  26. Letter 686 to Anatoly Tchaikovsky, 11/23–14/26 December 1877. ↩︎

  27. Letter 690 to Pyotr Jurgenson, 15/27 December 1877. ↩︎

  28. Letter 691 to Anatoly Tchaikovsky, 15/27–17/29 December 1877. ↩︎

  29. Letter 692 to Nadezhda von Meck, 16/28 December 1877. ↩︎

  30. Letter 696 to Nadezhda von Meck, 20 December 1877/1 January 1878. ↩︎

  31. See Letter 700 to Anatoly Tchaikovsky, 21 December 1877/2 January 1878. ↩︎

  32. Letter 702 to Nikolay Rubinstein, 23 December 1877/4 January 1878. ↩︎

  33. Letter 708 to Anatoly Tchaikovsky, 24 December 1877/5 January 1878–25 December 1877/6 January 1878. ↩︎

  34. Letter 709 to Anatoly Tchaikovsky, 26 December 1877/7 January 1878. ↩︎

  35. See Letter 711 to Nadezhda von Meck, 30 December 1877/11 January 1878. ↩︎

  36. Letter 713 to Nikolay Rubinstein, 1/13 January 1878. ↩︎

  37. Letter 711 to Nadezhda von Meck, 30 December 1877/11 January 1878. ↩︎

  38. Letter 763 to Nadezhda von Meck, 17 February/1 March 1878. ↩︎

  39. Letter from Modest Tchaikovsky to the composer, 23 November/5 December–25 November/7 December 1878. ↩︎

  40. Letter from Sergey Taneyev to the composer, 18/30 March 1878 — Klin House-Museum Archive. ↩︎

  41. Letter 799 to Sergey Taneyev, 27 March/8 April 1878. ↩︎

  42. Letter 985 to Nadezhda von Meck, 26 November/8 December 1878. ↩︎

  43. Letter 3572 to Nadezhda von Meck, 18/30 May 1888. ↩︎

  44. See Letter 725 to Pyotr Jurgenson, 12/24 January 1878. ↩︎

  45. See Letter 724 to Pyotr Jurgenson, 1/13 January 1878. ↩︎

  46. See Letter 716 to Sergey Taneyev, 2/14 January 1878, and Taneyev's reply to Tchaikovsky, 8/20 November 1878. ↩︎

  47. See Letter 1154 to Nadezhda von Meck, 14/26 April 1879. ↩︎

  48. Letter 959 to Nadezhda von Meck, 6/18 November 1878. ↩︎

  49. See Letter from Pyotr Jurgenson to Tchaikovsky, 6/18 September 1880 — Klin House-Museum Archive.

  50. See Letter 1297 to Nadezhda von Meck, 25 September/7 October 1879.

  51. First advertised by Eulenburg in Hofmeister's Musikalisch-literarischer Monatsbericht (December 1902), p. 638, 640.

  52. See Letter 574 to Nadezhda von Meck, 3/15 July 1877, and Letter 800 to Pyotr Jurgenson, 27 March/8 April 1878. ↩︎

Sources

Licence: CC BY-NC-SA 4.0. Tchaikovsky Research (en.tchaikovsky-research.net).

Cite this page

Plain text

Symphony No. 4. Dear Tchaikovsky, https://deartchaikovsky.com/en/works/th27-symphony-no-4/. Last updated 18 November 2026.

Chicago

“Symphony No. 4.” Dear Tchaikovsky. Last updated 18 November 2026. https://deartchaikovsky.com/en/works/th27-symphony-no-4/.

BibTeX

@misc{deartchaikovsky-works-th27-symphony-no-4,
  title = {Symphony No. 4},
  howpublished = {Dear Tchaikovsky},
  url = {https://deartchaikovsky.com/en/works/th27-symphony-no-4/},
  date = {2026-11-18},
}