Tchaikovsky and Mily Balakirev
The leader of the Saint Petersburg nationalists hoped to bring Tchaikovsky into his circle and never did, but he shaped two of his best-known works. In 1869 he proposed Romeo and Juliet, laid out its plan and keys, and pressed him to revise it. In 1882 he sent Tchaikovsky a programme for a Manfred symphony, a version of one Vladimir Stasov had written in 1867, and kept at him until Manfred was written in 1885. Tchaikovsky dedicated Fatum, Romeo and Juliet and Manfred to him.
Dates and places
April 1868 · Saint Petersburg
On a visit to Saint Petersburg he met Balakirev and his circle.
August 1869 · Moscow
Balakirev spent late summer in Moscow and saw him daily; it was then that he proposed an overture on Romeo and Juliet.
October 1884 · Saint Petersburg
After a coolness they made it up, and Balakirev raised Manfred again and sent the programme a second time.
In his letters
“Balakirev is leaving today: no matter how exhausting he is, it's only fair to say that he's a very honest and good man, and as an artist he stands immeasurably higher than the average.”
“You can then tear it to pieces as much as you like; I shall take note of everything and in my next composition I will try to do things better.”
“I'm more frightened of Balakirev than almost everyone in the world.”
“Balakirev so pestered me with this Manfred that I caved in and gave my word.”
In their words
“The first D-flat major theme is beautiful, although somewhat overripe, but the second D-flat tune is simply delightful”
