Continue readingShow less 8 more paragraphs
My dear chap! You seem to think that composing ceremonial pieces for the occasion of an exhibition is some sort of supreme bliss, of which I shall rush to take advantage, and immediately begin pouring out my inspiration, without having a fair idea of how, what, why, when, etc. I won't lift a single finger until something is commissioned from me. If they want me to set a text for something vocal, then let them send whatever text they like (for a commission I'm even prepared to set Tchaikovsky the pharmacist's advert for corn medicine to music); if they want me to write something instrumental, then let them set out what, exactly, in what form, and to illustrate what event. At the same time, it's essential: 1) to stipulate a fixed fee, with a precise indication of when and from whom I will receive it, and 2) to stipulate a fixed period of time. And so, talk to whomever you need to find out and determine all this. I'm not demanding all this on a whim, but just because otherwise I cannot compose things like this, i.e. anything ceremonial, unless they tell me clearly and precisely what is required from me, for how much, and for how long. There are two inspirations: one emerges directly from the heart with a free choice of this or that motive for creativity; the other is to order. The latter requires motivation, encouragement and means of inspiration in the form of precise instructions, fixed periods of time and the prospect in the more or less distant future of (many) Catherines [5]. You present me with a choice of this or that ceremonial event, as if I could be seduced by one of them! And if I'm personally to blame for not answering you earlier, you are mistaken to say that this is a business matter. Business questions ought to be clear and precise. Just imagine that I'd been able to inspire myself and write a ceremonial overture for the opening of an exhibition. What then? Would it turn out that the great Anton for his part had done something Antonesque? What would have happened to my scribblings? Therefore: precise, clear instructions and terms, and if it's with text, then supply the text. Until then I won't even think about the exhibition or the music accompanying it.
Replying to a further letter from Jurgenson on 3/15 July, he again expressed his "extreme aversion" to the task work:
Regarding the exhibition music, I say to you that, of course, I ought to have given you some sort of reply to your first proposal, and if I didn't do this, it's because I didn't take your words as something already settled and requiring an answer, but merely as a suggestion that if there was supposed to be music at the exhibition, then I ought to write something [...] Indeed, how can I not have an extreme aversion to setting about music intended to glorify that which, in essence, I'm not in the least enthusiastic about. There's nothing at all to catch my inspiration, neither in the jubilee of a high-ranking personage (who has always been quite antipathetic towards me), nor in the cathedral, which doesn't appeal to me at all" [6].
In subsequent letters, the composer again pressed Jurgenson for exact details of the character and of the length of the commissioned work [7]. At this point he seemed to be considering an orchestral work with chorus, and in a letter of 1/13 September 1880 he wrote to Jurgenson to send him Stepan Ponomarev's collection Moscow in Native Poetry. "I have great need of this book, because I hope to find something in it for my exhibition music, which I'm intending to set about composing shortly, and to tell the truth, with an inexplicable loathing. Be so good as to see about ordering and purchasing this book. Have you told Nikolay Grigoryevich that I want more precise and detailed instructions about what is required from me?" [8].
On 18/30 September, Nikolay Rubinstein himself sent Tchaikovsky a personal request for him to write a piece in any form, between 15 and 25 minutes in duration, to be submitted between 1/13 December 1880 and 15/27 January 1881 [9]. Writing to Nadezhda von Meck of 28 September/10 October 1880, Tchaikovsky complained: "There is nothing more antipathetic to me than composing for the sake of some festivities or other. Just imagine, my dear friend! What, for instance, might one write on the occasion of the opening of an exhibition, besides banalities and generally noisy passages? However, I do not have it in my heart to refuse such a request, and so I'm obliged to set about this disagreeable task" [10].
In a letter to Nadezhda von Meck of 30 September/12 October 1880, he reported: "Despite being somewhat averse to the exhibition music, I have quite diligently set about it, in order to quickly remove from my shoulders this burden that weighs heavily upon me" [11].
On 6/18 October the composer told Anatoly Tchaikovsky [12] that he had finished the overture for the exhibition, and on 10/22 October he wrote to Nadezhda von Meck: "The muse has been kind to me recently... so that with good speed I have written two things, namely: 1) a grand festival overture for the exhibition, at the request of Nikolay Grigoryevich, and 2) a Serenade for String Orchestra, in four movements. Both of these I am now orchestrating little by little. The Overture will be very loud and noisy—but I wrote it without any warm and loving feelings, and consequently it will probably be lacking in artistic merit" [13]. In 1882 the composer told Pyotr Jurgenson: "I absolutely do not know whether my overture ("The Year 1812") is good or bad, but I rather think it is the former (pardon my immodesty)" [14].
On 27 October/8 November 1880, Tchaikovsky, in a letter to Nadezhda von Meck, complaining of acute headaches and finding it impossible to work, wrote: "All at once I am finding that minor problems are very burdensome and worrying to me, since I have barely begun the instrumentation of the overture for the exhibition" [15].
According to the date on the manuscript, the full score was completed on 7/19 November 1880.