The passages people recognise, as simplified melody lines you can play. Underlined musical terms open the terms page.
The main theme
First movement, Moderato assai, bars 28–33. Solo violin, after its short entrance over the orchestra.
After the orchestra's introduction, whose theme never returns, the soloist begins quietly with this singing tune in D major. Listen for the little turn of quick notes before each phrase climbs. Later in the movement Tchaikovsky's own cadenza leads straight back into it.
The notation and its sound need JavaScript. The text above says what to listen for.
Second movement, Canzonetta (Andante), from bar 12. Solo violin, muted, after a short introduction for the woodwinds.
The score marks the solo con sordino: a small clamp on the bridge, a mute, veils the violin's tone. The tune is in G minor and moves mostly by step, with three repeated D's leaning forward. The excerpt stops on the trilled D; the melody goes on with a quick turn.
The notation and its sound need JavaScript. The text above says what to listen for.
Third movement, Finale (Allegro vivacissimo), the solo's first statement of the main theme, at Tempo I. Low on the violin.
A quick Russian-sounding dance starts low, on the violin's lowest string, and climbs in running notes. The orchestra keeps a drone-like bass under it. The finale follows the Canzonetta without a break.
The notation and its sound need JavaScript. The text above says what to listen for.
In March 1878, staying at Clarens on Lake Geneva with his former student, the violinist Iosif Kotek, Tchaikovsky put aside a piano sonata and sketched a violin concerto in eleven days; he replaced the slow movement and finished the full score by mid-April. Leopold Auer, who was to give the first performance in Saint Petersburg in 1879, found it too difficult, and for a while it was thought unplayable. Adolph Brodsky took it up, and his performance in Vienna in December 1881, conducted by Hans Richter, made its name.
Instrumentation
The concerto is scored for solo violin and an orchestra consisting of 2 flutes, 2 oboes, 2 clarinets (in A, B-flat), 2 bassoons + 4 horns (in F), 2 trumpets (in D) + 2 timpani + violins I, violins II, violas, cellos, and double basses.
Movements and duration
There are three movements:
Allegro moderato—Moderato assai (D major, 339 bars)
Canzonetta. Andante (G minor, 119 bars)
Finale. Allegro vivacissimo (D major, 639 bars)
The concerto lasts approximately 30 to 35 minutes in performance.
Composition
Early in 1878, Tchaikovsky was staying at Clarens as a guest, with his former student, the violinist Iosif Kotek. Together with Kotek, he played through a large selection from the violin repertoire, and in particular the French composer Lalo's Symphonie espagnole which it seems inspired him to write a violin concerto [1].
On 5/17 March, Tchaikovsky wrote to Nadezhda von Meck: "...this morning I was overcome by that unfathomable burning inspiration I told you about... Besides small pieces, I am writing a sonata for piano and a violin concerto" [2]. He set aside his Grand Sonata, on which he had been working at the time, and began composition of the Violin Concerto [3]. In a letter to Nadezhda von Meck of 7/19 March, Tchaikovsky noted that for the first time in his life he had begun a new composition before completing the previous one. "On this occasion I could not overcome my desire to make rough sketches for a concerto, and afterwards became so carried away that I abandoned work on the sonata" [4]. In all his letters from this period, the composer remarks that he is carried away with work on the concerto, which, notwithstanding its novelty of form, came very easily to him. On 10/22 March, i.e. after five days, Tchaikovsky finished the first movement of the concerto; on 11/23 March he began the second movement (Andante), and on 14/26 March he told Nadezhda von Meck that he had "reached the finale" and the concerto would soon be ready [5]. On 16/28 March 1878, Tchaikovsky wrote: "Today I finished the concerto. It still has to be copied out and played through a few times... and then orchestrated. I shall start the copying out and add the finishing touches" [6]. The following day he began to make the fair copy [7].
Continue readingShow less2 more paragraphs
After playing through the concerto with Iosif Kotek, Tchaikovsky decided to write a new Andante, though the first movement and finale were considered satisfactory [8]. On 24 March/5 April, Tchaikovsky wrote the new Andante, which in his words was: "better suited to the concerto's other two movements". He decided to add two other violin pieces to the original Andante (which was restyled Méditation) to form the cycle Souvenir d'un lieu cher, Op. 42) [9].
Therefore, by 24 March/5 April all the sketches were ready, including the new Andante, and the piano arrangement of the first movement. In a letter of 24 March/5 April, Tchaikovsky told Nadezhda von Meck: "Today my concerto might be called completely finished. Tomorrow I shall launch myself into the full score, and aim to finish this while the work is still fresh in my thoughts". On 30 March/11 April the full score was ready [10].
Arrangements
Tchaikovsky also arranged the concerto for violin with piano accompaniment, between 17/29 March [11] and 24 March 1878 [12].
Performances
The first performance of the concerto was scheduled for 10/22 March 1879 at a concert of the Russian Musical Society in Saint Petersburg, to be performed by Leopold Auer[13]. But Auer and Karl Davydov declared that it was too difficult, and the performance of the concerto did not take place. Attempts by Iosif Kotek and Emile Sauret to play the concerto in Moscow were also unsuccessful. The concerto gained a reputation as unplayable, and no-one would perform it [14]. The concerto was reportedly performed for the first time in 1879 (in the version for violin with piano) in New York by the violinist Leopold Damrosch[15].
In Europe, and later in Russia, the foremost performer and advocate of the concerto was Adolph Brodsky. Enraptured by the concerto, Brodsky introduced it in Vienna, at a special Novitätenprobe[16], conducted by Hans Richter. After the preliminary hearing, it was approved for performance at the third Philharmonic Society subscription concert on 22 November/4 December 1881. Its success was sensational, despite an unfavourable reception by parts of the audience. The critics behaved with hostility to the work, particularly the well-known critic Eduard Hanslick. Nevertheless, the concerto attracted considerable attention, and Brodsky received numerous offers for concerts in the following season [17].
Continue readingShow less3 more paragraphs
Although Brodsky's 1881 performance in Vienna was for many years presumed to have been the concerto's world premiere, evidence has recently been found to show that it was performed in Hannover on 1/13 March 1880, by the concertmaster of the city's Hofkapelle, Georg Haenflein, conducted by Ernst Frank. It seems that Tchaikovsky was unaware of this performance, which seems to have attracted little attention outside Hannover itself [18].
In Russia, the Violin Concerto was performed for the first time on 8/20 August 1882 at the sixth concert in the Art and Industrial Exhibition in Moscow, by Adolph Brodsky, conducted by Ippolit Altani, where it had exceptional success [19]. Other notable performances during the composer's lifetime were:
London, St. James's Hall, 26 April/8 May 1882, Adolph Brodsky (violin), conducted by Hans Richter
Karlsruhe, 1st subscription concert, 16/28 October 1882, Adolph Brodsky (violin)
In Tchaikovsky's Complete Collected Works the full score of the Concerto was published in volume 30A, edited by Valentina Rachkovskaya (1949), and the violin-piano arrangement in volume 55A, edited by Ivan Shishov and Nikolay Shemanin (1946).
Series 3, Volumes 5 and 6 of the Academic Edition of the Complete Works, edited by Polina Vaidman and Ada Aynbinder (2019), include the full scores and violin-piano arrangements of the concerto.
Autographs
Tchaikovsky's manuscript full score of the concerto is now preserved in the Glinka National Museum Consortium of Musical Culture in Moscow. The whereabouts of the manuscript of his arrangement for violin and piano are unknown.
Dedication
After some vacillation over who the dedicatee of the concerto should be— Iosif Kotek or Leopold Auer—Tchaikovsky initially decided upon the latter [21]. However, as a result of Auer's persistent refusal to play the concerto, the composer withdrew the original dedication and replaced it with "À Monsieur Adolphe Brodsky" [22], after being impressed by the young violinist's enthusiasm for the work.
Where he wrote it
March–April 1878: 1 stay in 1 place. Numbered in the order he reached each place, from where he came from to where he went next, traced from the place and date of his letters.
Dates are New Style (N.S.), the calendar used in the West. In Russia, on the Old Style calendar, the date was 12 days earlier.
Composed hereStayed while writingBefore and after
1Came fromFlorence21 February – 7 March 1878 · 14 letters
What he said about this work in his letters, from the first mention to the last. Each passage is quoted word for word from the letter; open the letter to read the rest.
While composing, 1878
I sat all morning over a violin concerto, which I started yesterday and became carried away to such an extent that I've abandoned the sonata for the time being.
I started to write the Andante of the Violin Concerto. Modya received your letter, and was very upset that he still owed so much to both Charmer and Gaudin.
I'm finishing a violin concerto. Somehow, quite by chance, I came up with an idea for it, sat down, became engrossed, and now the work is almost ready in draft.
I finished the concerto today. All that remains is to write it out, play it through a few times (with Kotek, who is still here) and then to orchestrate it.
You will receive my concerto before it is printed. I shall commission a copy of it, and I daresay this will be delivered to you over the course of the next month.
I received it some two weeks ago, just when I was starting to write a violin concerto, which I am now hurrying to finish, so that it is completely ready by the time of my departure, which will take place next week.
Now, my friend, I would ask you to compile an account of what I owe you, and what you owe me, inclusive of the fees for the opera and for the violin concerto.
For quite a while, Kotek has been asking me for the following two items: 1) some singer, Schulzen-Asten, wishes to have my picture with my inscription, and 2) the violinist de Ana wishes to have my concerto.
The Philharmonic Society wants to give 2 concerts in winter exclusively of my works, and asking what programme I want. I answered and indicated, amongst other things, the Violin Concerto, and at the same time recommended Kotek to them.
Yesterday I received a letter from Pyotr Ivanovich, in which he described the dirty tricks that Auer has been up to in order to prevent Sauret and Kotek from playing my concerto.
Amongst other things, he reviews my violin concerto and it's so curious that I advise you to obtain it (unfortunately I didn't have the presence of mind to note the number).
I had no reply to my letter, which I told you about in Kiev, but instead he went to Petersburg and, on his return, wrote that he couldn't play because Sauret would be playing my concerto.
"Onegin" isn't going on, Auer is using dirty tricks against the violin concerto, no-one is playing the (second) piano concerto — in short, this is bad!
If you want one or the other of them to play my concerto, then I definitively opt for Brodsky, and ask you to keep my statement in mind in case the question needs to be resolved: which of the two?
A concert made up solely of my works is scheduled for 8th August, and among these, apart from Brodsky with the Violin Concerto, the overture which I wrote for the Exhibition is to be performed.
Furthermore, they say that if the Violin Concerto is torn to pieces in the press, then it will be difficult to correct this bad impression, whereas on 8 February, if one thing is a flop then something else will find favour, and ultimately…
The score of the violin concerto is in one of the cases which is coming or has already arrived from Paris. I'll bring the full score of the "Pezzo" with me.
Thank you very much for your friendly lines, but the feeling is quite mutual. Thanks also for having played my Violin Concerto so frequently in Pavlovsk.
…of the latter. 1st section 1) Symphony in D major by Mozart. 2) Brodsky plays my concerto, though, come to think of it, this it is by no means essential that it should be mine as such—you can play whatever concerto you like. 3) Passepied…
The programme is: 1) Symphony in D major by Mozart 2) Violin Concerto by Tchaikovsky (Brodsky) 3) Excerpts from Mozart's Idomeneo 4) Overture by Taneyev 5) Small pieces for violin 6) Jota aragonesa by Glinka
Brodsky is pressing me to find his parts for my violin concerto in the library of our Musical Society. He has asked several times for them to be returned to him, but in vain.
1) In Petersburg last April, Auer asked me to tell you that he would very much like... and what exactly, by God, I've forgotten, but I think it was to be invited to play my Violin Concerto next season in Moscow.
March 1878 At Clarens in Switzerland with Iosif Kotek, he writes his Violin Concerto.
January 1878 He travels to San Remo, where he completes the Symphony No. 4 and Yevgeny Onegin.
13/25 January 1878 Death of his half-sister Zinayda.
10/22 February 1878 Premiere of the Symphony No. 4.
May 1878 He returns to Russia and spends time at Kamenka, before moving on to the Brailov country estate of Nadezhda von Meck, who is absent. Here he writes the Souvenir d'un lieu cher as a memento of his stay, and the Liturgy of Saint John Chrysostom.
August 1878 He starts work on the Suite No. 1.
September 1878 He returns to the Moscow Conservatory to resume teaching.
7/19 October 1878 He leaves the Moscow Conservatory for good.
December 1878 He travels to Italy and settles in Florence, where he starts work on The Maid of Orleans.
See letter from Nadezhda von Meck to Tchaikovsky, 27 December 1881/8 January 1882, and "Ignotus" [i.e. Sergey Flerov], Музыкальная хроника (1881). The exact date of this supposed performance is unknown, and it has yet to be corroborated by contemporary accounts. ↩︎
See letters from Adolph Brodsky to Tchaikovsky, January–June 1882 — Klin House-Museum Archive. ↩︎
For a full description of the background to this performance, see Brett Langston, An 'Accidental' Premiere? New Information on the First Performance of Čajkovskij’s Violin Concerto (2023). ↩︎