Instrumentation
Scored for high voice (Nos. 1, 5), medium voice (Nos. 3, 4), baritone (No. 2) or low voice (No. 6), with piano accompaniment.
Movements and duration
#Tell Me, What in the Shade of the Branches? (Скажи, о чем в тени ветвей)
Andante sostenuto (E major, 63 bars).
#On the Golden Cornfields (На нивы желтые)
Andante (F minor, 36 bars).
#Do Not Ask (Не спрашивай)
Adagio molto sostenuto (D major, 32 bars).
#Sleep! (Усни!)
Andante sostenuto (F major, 53 bars).
#Death (Смерть)
Moderato (F major, 75 bars).
#Only You Alone (Лишь ты один)
Andante non troppo (F major, 36 bars).
Texts
1. Vladimir Sollogub (1813–1882)[1], from Marta Petrovna's romance in his comedy-vaudeville Trouble from a Tender Heart (Беда от нежного сердца) (1850):
2. Aleksey Tolstoy (1817–1875), from an untitled poem (1862):
3. Aleksandr Strugovshchikov (1808/9–1878/9), from his translation (1845) of Heiß mich nicht reden, in book 3 of the novel Wilhelm Meisters Lehrjahre (1795) by Johann Wolfgang von Goethe (1749–1832):
4. Dmitry Merezhkovsky (1865–1941), from his poem of the same name (1884):
5. Dmitry Merezhkovsky, from an untitled poem (by 1883):
6. Aleksey Pleshcheyev (1825–1893), from an untitled poem (1884), after the German poem Nur Du allein (1872) by Ada Christen (1844–1901) [2]:
Tchaikovsky made minor changes to the texts of the poems used in On the Golden Cornfields (No. 2), Do Not Ask! (No. 3), Sleep! (No. 4), and more significant changes in Only You Alone (No. 6).
Composition
The earliest of the romances to be written was Tell Me, What in the Shade of the Branches? (No. 1). In a letter to Pyotr Jurgenson of 1/13 December 1884 (see below), the composer expressed his surprise at this discovery of this romance, which it seems he had forgotten about [3]. The exact time and place of its composition are uncertain.
On the Golden Cornfields (No. 2) and Do Not Ask (No. 3) were composed at Pleshcheyevo in late September 1884. Before the rough draft of No. 2 in the composer's notebook is the date "Pleshcheyevo, 26 Sept 1884" (O.S.). Do Not Ask (No. 3) was composed next, and its text was probably chosen by Tchaikovsky after he read Goethe's novel The Apprenticeship of Wilhelm Meister ("God, how marvellous this is..."), which he found in Nadezhda von Meck's library at Pleshcheyevo [4].
Continue readingShow less 2 more paragraphs
The remaining three romances were written in Paris between 19 November/1 December (the date of his arrival) and 1/13 December 1884, when Tchaikovsky wrote to Pyotr Jurgenson: "I was very surprised to learn that Komissarzhevsky has my romance. Incidentally, I already have another five. Congratulations to you on my new opus" [5].
Writing to Modest Tchaikovsky from Paris on 3/15 December 1884, the composer reported: "I cannot say that I am bored from idleness. I managed here to devise the main revisions to Vakula, and to write three new romances, and one church number" [6].
Publication
The romances were published by Jurgenson in April 1885 [7], and in 1940 they were included in volume 45 of Tchaikovsky's Complete Collected Works, edited by Ivan Shishov and Nikolay Shemanin.
Autographs
Tchaikovsky's manuscript scores of Nos. 2 to 6 are now preserved in the Glinka National Museum Consortium of Musical Culture in Moscow. The autograph of No. 1 is lost.
Dedications
Each romance is dedicated to a different person:
- Fyodor Komissarzhevsky (1838–1905), the tenor who premiered the title role in Vakula the Smith in 1876.
- Bogomir Korsov (1845–1920), the baritone who premiered the title role in Mazepa in 1884.
- Emiliya Pavlovskaya (1856–1935), the soprano who premiered the role of Mariya in Mazepa.
- Vera Butakova (1843–1920) [8], younger sister of Lev Davydov (the husband of Tchaikovsky's sister Aleksandra Davydova).
- Dmitry Usatov (1847–1913), tenor who premiered the role of Andrey in Mazepa.
- Aleksandra Krutikova (1851–1919), mezzo-soprano who premiered the role of Lyubov in Mazepa.