To Michał Hertz

From
Pyotr Ilyich Tchaikovsky
To
Michał Hertz
Written at
Saint Petersburg
Tchaikovsky Research no.
5020
Where the autograph is kept
Moscow (Russia): Bakhrushin State Central Theatre Museum, Moscow
Translation
English: Luis Sundkvist (Tchaikovsky Research)
Cite this page

Plain text

Pyotr Ilyich Tchaikovsky. Tchaikovsky to Michał Hertz, 23 August / 4 September 1893 (Letter 5020). Translated by Luis Sundkvist (Tchaikovsky Research). Dear Tchaikovsky, https://deartchaikovsky.com/en/letters/5020/. Last updated 18 November 2026. Printed in П. И. Чайковский. Полное собрание сочинений; том XVII (1981), p. 174–175.

Chicago

Tchaikovsky, Pyotr Ilyich. “Tchaikovsky to Michał Hertz, 23 August / 4 September 1893 (Letter 5020).” Translated by Luis Sundkvist (Tchaikovsky Research). Dear Tchaikovsky. Last updated 18 November 2026. https://deartchaikovsky.com/en/letters/5020/. Printed in П. И. Чайковский. Полное собрание сочинений; том XVII (1981), p. 174–175.

BibTeX

@misc{deartchaikovsky-letters-5020,
  author = {Pyotr Ilyich Tchaikovsky},
  title = {Tchaikovsky to Michał Hertz, 23 August / 4 September 1893 (Letter 5020)},
  note = {Translated by Luis Sundkvist (Tchaikovsky Research). Printed in П. И. Чайковский. Полное собрание сочинений; том XVII (1981), p. 174–175.},
  howpublished = {Dear Tchaikovsky},
  url = {https://deartchaikovsky.com/en/letters/5020/},
  date = {2026-11-18},
}

Original in German

Moskau
23 August 1893

Sehr geehrter Herr! Die Musik[,] die ich vor einigen Jahren zu Hamlet geschrieben habe, ist eigentlich kein ernstes Kunstwerk. Ich habe sie nämlich für die Benefiz-Vorstellung von einem Freunde sehr schnell gemacht[,] nur um ihm das Vergnügen zu schaffen[,] meinen Namen auf der Annonce drucken zu lassen. Sie ist für ein ganz kleines Orchester orchestrirt und passt zu einem grossen Kaiserlichen Theater nicht. Daher rahte ich Ihnen[,] meine so genannte Hamlet-Musik nicht zu spielen. Ich habe eine grosse Hamlet-Ouvertüre componirt; Sie könnten sie spielen, aber sie ist zu gross, mehr eine Simphonische Dichtung als Ouvertüre und braucht einen sehr starkes Orchester.

Ich empfehle Ihnen die schöne Hamlet-Musik von Georg Henschel.

Jedenfalls kann ich Ihnen in Ihrer Verlegenheit nicht helfen, da ich selbst vollständig vergessen habe[,] wie und wann, d. h. bei welchen Scenen und Worten die Musik einfallen soll.

Bitte um Entschuldigung.

Ihr ergebenster,

P. Tschaikovsky

English translation

Moscow [1]
23 August 1893

Most respected Sir! The music for Hamlet which I wrote a few years ago is not really a serious work of art. I wrote it in fact very quickly for the benefit performance of a friend [2], just to afford him the pleasure of being able to print my name on the playbill. It is scored for a very small orchestra and is not suitable for a large imperial theatre. I therefore recommend you not to play my so-called Hamlet music [3]. I have composed a big Hamlet overture: you could play that, though it is too big—more of a symphonic poem than an overture—and requires a very strong orchestra.

I recommend to you the beautiful Hamlet music by George Henschel [4].

In any case, I cannot help you out of your predicament, because I have myself completely forgotten how and when, i.e. at which scenes and lines the music is supposed to set in.

I beg your forgiveness.

Your most devoted,

P. Tchaikovsky

What to listen to

Around this letter

KlinSaint PetersburgHamburgKlinSaint PetersburgHamburg
  1. BeforeKlin30 July – 1 September 1893
  2. HereSaint Petersburg4 September 1893
  3. AfterHamburg9 September 1893

Named in this letter

Letters from the same weeks

On his desk at the time

Published in

  • Чайковский на Московской сцене (1940), p. 484–485
  • Чайковский и зарубежные музыканты (1970), p. 86
  • П. И. Чайковский. Полное собрание сочинений; том XVII (1981), p. 174–175.

Notes

  1. This appears to have been a slip of the pen by Tchaikovsky, who was in Saint Petersburg at this time.

  2. The French actor Lucien Guitry.

  3. Michał Hertz had written (in German) to Tchaikovsky on 16/28 August 1893, explaining that the Warsaw Theatre intended to stage Shakespeare's Hamlet using Tchaikovsky's incidental music. He asked Tchaikovsky if he could provide more specific indications as to the scenes and lines in the play which were meant to be illustrated by the musical numbers in the score published by Jurgenson. Hertz's letter is included in Чайковский на московской сцене (1940), p. 482–483.

  4. The German-born British singer, conductor and composer Sir George Henschel (1850–1934) composed his incidental music to Hamlet for the actor-manager Sir Herbert Beerbohm Tree's acclaimed production of the tragedy at the Haymarket Theatre, London, in 1892. Tchaikovsky had been acquainted with Henschel since 1875, and during his last visit to London in June 1893 he spent some time with Henschel and his family. It is likely that on this occasion Henschel showed him the score of his incidental music for Hamlet which had been published in September 1892 — see Stanford, the Cambridge Jubilee, and Tchaikovsky (1980), p. 401–402.

Sources

Licence: CC BY-NC-SA 4.0. Tchaikovsky Research (en.tchaikovsky-research.net).