Mr Gilfil's Love Story

In 1893, Tchaikovsky considered writing operas based on two of the stories from the collection Scenes of Clerical Life (1857) by the English writer Mary Ann Evans (1819–1880), published under her literary pseudonym of "George Eliot". The second of these subjects was Mr Gilfil's Love Story (Любовь Мистера Гильфиля) [1].

Modest Tchaikovsky recalled that after first considering The Sad Fortunes of the Reverend Amos Barton (the first story in the trilogy) as an opera subject, the composer changed his mind in favour of Mr Gilfil's Love Story [2]. Herman Laroche also remembered that "During the current summer [of 1893], amongst other things, he had read a French translation of the Scenes of Clerical Life by George Eliot, for whose novels, beginning with The Mill on the Floss, he had an extremely strong affection during the last years of his life. Among the stories which make up this book was Mr Gilfil's Love Story, the action of which takes place in the eighteenth century, and whose pathos particularly captivated him. He found that this subject 'should be well-suited for writing an opera'" [3].

After Tchaikovsky's death, a brief scenario for Acts II and III of an opera on Mr Gilfil's Love Story was discovered amongst his papers [4]: Act II, Scene 1 — various scenes: 1) between the Captain and his fiancée; 2) between Tina and the Captain; 3) between Tina, the fiancée, the Captain and Gilfil, out of which is explained their relationships to each other, Tina's jealousy, the fiancée's jealousy, the truth of the captain's situation, everyone's worsening health, Tina's rudeness, the challenge of her explanation from the Lord, her decision to leave him for Gilfil, Gilfil's suffering and jealousy, etc. All of this should take place in the park. Scene 2 — Evening in the large hall of the castle. Tina is asked to sing. She sings the second aria from the first act, but so enchantingly that all are amazed (something similar to Adrienne Lecouvreur), and the Captain is seized and unexpectedly picks up a dagger and leaps at her, but just in time she runs. The Captain lets out a cry, and dies. General terror and despair. Tina falls in a faint. Act III — Tina is taking refuge at Dorcas's house, in a miserable state. Gilfil appears, happy to have found her, and commiserates with her situation. His attempts to talk with her are unsuccessful. Gilfil, after his earlier short scenes, explains how everything has come about, a tortured reminder of her first aria. She listens and begins to sing and then cries, taking hold of herself, and all ends almost happily, but with a hint of melancholy. She does not become engaged to Gilfil, but leaves him with the hope that she will love him. [5].

No other documents relating to the opera have come to light.

Genre
Unfinished and projected
Composed
1893
Description
Projected opera
Catalogue
TH 245 · ČW 464

Where he wrote it

1893: 43 stays in 16 places. Numbered in the order he reached each place, from where he came from to where he went next, traced from the place and date of his letters.

Dates are New Style (N.S.), the calendar used in the West. In Russia, on the Old Style calendar, the date was 12 days earlier.

1893: 43 stays in 16 places.1. Basel12. Montbéliard23. Paris34. Brussels45. Odessa56. Kamenka67. Kharkov78. Klin89. Moscow910. Saint Petersburg1011. Berlin1112. London1213. Cambridge1314. Grankino1415. Ukolovo1516. Hamburg1617. Mikhaylovskoye17KlinMoscowParisSaint PetersburgLondonGrankinoBaselBrusselsOdessaBerlinKamenkaKharkovMikhaylovskoyeMontbéliardCambridgeUkolovoHamburg

Composed hereStayed while writingBefore and after

  1. Came fromBasel30 December – 31 December 1892 · 4 letters
  2. Montbéliard1 January 1893 · 1 letter
  3. Paris3 January – 5 January 1893 · 2 letters
  4. Brussels10 January – 12 January 1893 · 4 letters
  5. Paris16 January – 19 January 1893 · 10 letters
  6. Odessa27 January – 5 February 1893 · 4 letters
  7. Kamenka8 February – 10 February 1893 · 3 letters
  8. Kharkov14 February 1893 · 1 letter
  9. Klin15 February – 23 February 1893 · 13 letters
  10. Moscow28 February 1893 · 4 letters
  11. Klin4 March 1893 · 1 letter
33 more stays
  1. Moscow4 March – 11 March 1893 · 3 letters
  2. Klin12 March – 14 March 1893 · 8 letters
  3. Moscow14 March 1893 · 1 letter
  4. Klin16 March 1893 · 4 letters
  5. Moscow19 March – 22 March 1893 · 6 letters
  6. Kharkov23 March 1893 · 1 letter
  7. Moscow30 March 1893 · 1 letter
  8. Klin30 March 1893 · 1 letter
  9. Moscow31 March 1893 · 1 letter
  10. Klin31 March – 6 April 1893 · 11 letters
  11. Saint Petersburg9 April 1893 · 1 letter
  12. Klin17 April – 2 May 1893 · 19 letters
  13. Moscow4 May – 14 May 1893 · 4 letters
  14. Klin15 May – 17 May 1893 · 5 letters
  15. Saint Petersburg18 May – 24 May 1893 · 2 letters
  16. Berlin27 May 1893 · 4 letters
  17. London29 May – 10 June 1893 · 13 letters
  18. Cambridge13 June 1893 · 1 letter
  19. London14 June 1893 · 1 letter
  20. Paris15 June – 27 June 1893 · 11 letters
  21. Grankino1 July – 15 July 1893 · 12 letters
  22. Ukolovo18 July 1893 · 1 letter
  23. Moscow30 July 1893 · 1 letter
  24. Klin30 July – 1 September 1893 · 57 letters
  25. Saint Petersburg4 September 1893 · 1 letter
  26. Hamburg9 September 1893 · 1 letter
  27. Saint Petersburg11 September – 16 September 1893 · 7 letters
  28. Moscow21 September 1893 · 1 letter
  29. Mikhaylovskoye24 September – 27 September 1893 · 2 letters
  30. Moscow29 September – 6 October 1893 · 11 letters
  31. Klin6 October – 19 October 1893 · 16 letters
  32. Moscow20 October 1893 · 1 letter
  33. Saint Petersburg30 October – 2 November 1893 · 6 letters

Hear it live

Concert listings worldwide are on Bachtrack. Upcoming Tchaikovsky concerts on Bachtrack

The world around this work

Who he was writing to and what else was happening in his life, 1893.

People around it

Whom he wrote to most in these years, and who appears in the letters about this work.

259 letters survive from these years. Letters of 1893

Meanwhile in his life

  • 1893 22 October/3 November–23 October/4 November – His condition gradually deteriorates.
  • 1893 26 October/7 November–27 October/8 November – Requiem services and tributes are held throughout Russia.
  • 20 December 1892 / 1 January 1893 He visits Fanny Dürbach in Montbéliard, France.
  • 2/14 January 1893 He conducts an all-Tchaikovsky concert in Brussels.
  • 12/24 January 1893 He arrives in Odessa to conduct a series of concerts of his own works, and to have his portrait painted by Nikolay Kuznetsov.
  • 25 January / 6 February 1893 He leaves Odessa for Kamenka and Kharkov.
  • 3/15 February 1893 He returns to Klin, where he starts to sketch the Symphony No. 6.
  • 11/23 March 1893 He arrives in Kharkov to conduct concerts of his own works.

Chronology 1893

In the world meanwhile

Places in this story

Klin

Listen next

Notes

  1. As "Mr. Gilfil's Lovestory" in ČW. ↩︎

  2. See Жизнь Петра Ильича Чайковского; том 3 (1902), p. 633. ↩︎

  3. Herman Laroche, Несколько слов о Петре Ильиче Чайковском (1893). ↩︎

  4. Klin House-Museum Archive (a2, No. 29). ↩︎

  5. Quoted from The Tchaikovsky Handbook, vol. 1 (2002), p. 421. ↩︎

Sources

Licence: CC BY-NC-SA 4.0. Tchaikovsky Research (en.tchaikovsky-research.net).

Cite this page

Plain text

Mr Gilfil's Love Story. Dear Tchaikovsky, https://deartchaikovsky.com/en/works/th245-mr-gilfils-love-story/. Last updated 18 November 2026.

Chicago

“Mr Gilfil's Love Story.” Dear Tchaikovsky. Last updated 18 November 2026. https://deartchaikovsky.com/en/works/th245-mr-gilfils-love-story/.

BibTeX

@misc{deartchaikovsky-works-th245-mr-gilfils-love-story,
  title = {Mr Gilfil's Love Story},
  howpublished = {Dear Tchaikovsky},
  url = {https://deartchaikovsky.com/en/works/th245-mr-gilfils-love-story/},
  date = {2026-11-18},
}