To Pyotr Jurgenson

From
Pyotr Ilyich Tchaikovsky
To
Pyotr Jurgenson
Written at
Frolovskoye
Tchaikovsky Research no.
4163
Where the autograph is kept
Klin (Russia): Tchaikovsky State House-Museum, Klin (a3, No. 2706)
Translation
English: Brett Langston (Tchaikovsky Research)
Cite this page

Plain text

Pyotr Ilyich Tchaikovsky. Tchaikovsky to Pyotr Jurgenson, 2/14 July 1890 (Letter 4163). Translated by Brett Langston (Tchaikovsky Research). Dear Tchaikovsky, https://deartchaikovsky.com/en/letters/4163/. Last updated 18 November 2026. Printed in П. И. Чайковский. Полное собрание сочинений; том XV-Б (1977), p. 197.

Chicago

Tchaikovsky, Pyotr Ilyich. “Tchaikovsky to Pyotr Jurgenson, 2/14 July 1890 (Letter 4163).” Translated by Brett Langston (Tchaikovsky Research). Dear Tchaikovsky. Last updated 18 November 2026. https://deartchaikovsky.com/en/letters/4163/. Printed in П. И. Чайковский. Полное собрание сочинений; том XV-Б (1977), p. 197.

BibTeX

@misc{deartchaikovsky-letters-4163,
  author = {Pyotr Ilyich Tchaikovsky},
  title = {Tchaikovsky to Pyotr Jurgenson, 2/14 July 1890 (Letter 4163)},
  note = {Translated by Brett Langston (Tchaikovsky Research). Printed in П. И. Чайковский. Полное собрание сочинений; том XV-Б (1977), p. 197.},
  howpublished = {Dear Tchaikovsky},
  url = {https://deartchaikovsky.com/en/letters/4163/},
  date = {2026-11-18},
}

Russian original

2-го июля

Милый друг! Рукопись кантаты в консерватории в Петербурге. Печатать её я не желаю, ибо это юношеское произведение без будущности; к тому же ведь она на текст «К радости» Шиллера. Соперничать с Бетховеном неловко.

«Кузнеца Вакулу» давно бы следовало уничтожить. Отдельные же нумера продавать, конечно, можно, но таковых, совсем не изменённых, очень немного.
1) Во 2-ом действии: антракт и сцена 4-я (я имею в виду нумерацию «Вакулы», а не «Черевичек»).
2) В 3-ем действии антракт и хор русалок.
3) В 3-ем действии Полонез, Менуэт, оба танцевальных нумера.
4) Дуэт Оксаны с Солохой («Кто говорит — утопился», и т. д.). Вот и все. Все остальные, в том числе и увертюра, изменены.

Переложение «Вакулы» в 2 руки — увы — надо бросить.

Очень жаль, но одно могу сказать в твоё утешение, это что в судьбу «Черевичек» как репертуарной оперы я безусловно верю и считаю её по музыке едва ли не самой лучшей моей оперой...

В Петров день кутежа настоящего не было. По правде сказать, было скучновато. В четверг я приеду или приду к тебе из Москвы, где у меня дело есть. Буду стремиться к Соломенной сторожке и искать № 16.

Твой П. Чайковский

Энгельмейера я не забыл. Отчего не получаю корректуры «Гамлета»??

Был у меня вчера Аренский; показывал задачник. Составлен превосходно и к учебнику моему вполне подходит. Советую приобрести.

Не пригласишь ли Аренского 5-го.

English translation

2nd July

Dear friend! The manuscript of the cantata is in the Petersburg conservatory [1]. I don't want to print it, because it's an immature work with no future; what's more, it's on the text of Schiller's "Ode to Joy". Comparisons with Beethoven would be embarrassing.

"Vakula the Smith" ought to have been destroyed long ago. Of course individual numbers could be sold, but very few of these have remained unchanged.
1) In the 2nd act: the entr'acte and 4th scene (I'm referring to the numeration of Vakula, rather than Cherevichki).
2) In the 3rd act, the entr'acte and chorus of rusalkas.
3) In the 3rd act, the Polonaise and Minuet are both dance numbers.
4) The duet for Oksana and Solokha ("Who says he has drowned", etc.). That is all. Everything else was altered, including the overture.

The arrangement of "Vakula" for 2 hands, alas, must be foresaken.

It's a great shame, but one thing I can say in consolation is that I am convinced that "Cherevichki" has a future as a repertoire opera, and musically I consider it to be one of my best operas.

Saint Peter's day wasn't actually a carousal. To tell the truth, it was tedious. On Thursday I'll come to you one way or another from Moscow, where I have business. I'll aim for the Straw Lodge and look for No. 16 [2].

Yours P. Tchaikovsky

I haven't forgotten Engelmeyer [3]. Why haven't I received the proofs of "Hamlet"??

I was with Arensky yesterday. He showed me the exercise book [4]. It is impeccably compiled and entirely suited to my guide. I advise you to purchase it.

Are you be inviting Arensky on the 5th.

What to listen to

Around this letter

Saint PetersburgFrolovskoyeMoscowSaint PetersburgFrolovskoyeMoscow
  1. BeforeSaint Petersburg8 May – 13 May 1890
  2. HereFrolovskoye15 May – 16 July 1890
  3. AfterMoscow18 July 1890

Named in this letter

Letters from the same weeks

On his desk at the time

Published in

  • Жизнь Петра Ильича Чайковского; том 3 (1902), p. 378 (abridged)
  • П. И. Чайковский. Переписка с П. И. Юргенсоном; том 2 (1952), p. 171
  • П. И. Чайковский. Полное собрание сочинений; том XV-Б (1977), p. 197

Notes

  1. In a letter to Tchaikovsky dated 30 June/12 July 1890, Pyotr Jurgenson had asked about the whereabouts of the composer's student cantata Ode to Joy, and also whether any fragments survived from the opera Vakula the Smith which hadn't been revised in Cherevichki.

  2. Jurgenson had invited the composer to his birthday celebrations on 5/17 July at a dacha near the historical Moscow landmark of the "Straw Lodge".

  3. Pyotr Klimetyevich Engelmeyer (1855-ca.1942), is predominantly remembered as a Russian engineer and author, but he was also an amateur composer whose romances Tchaikovsky had recently reviewed on Jurgenson's behalf.

  4. Anton Arensky's 1000 Collected Exercises for the Study of Harmony was eventually published by Jurgenson in 1897.

Sources

Licence: CC BY-NC-SA 4.0. Tchaikovsky Research (en.tchaikovsky-research.net).