Frolovskoye, 28 February / 12 March 1891 · Letter 4340
To Johann Armsheimer
- From
- Pyotr Ilyich Tchaikovsky
- To
- Johann Armsheimer
- Written at
- Frolovskoye
- Tchaikovsky Research no.
- 4340
- Where the autograph is kept
- Klin (Russia): Tchaikovsky State House-Museum, Klin (a3, No. 2986)
- Translation
- English: Brett Langston (Tchaikovsky Research)
Cite this page
Plain text
Pyotr Ilyich Tchaikovsky. Tchaikovsky to Johann Armsheimer, 28 February / 12 March 1891 (Letter 4340). Translated by Brett Langston (Tchaikovsky Research). Dear Tchaikovsky, https://deartchaikovsky.com/en/letters/4340/. Last updated 18 November 2026. Printed in П. И. Чайковский. Полное собрание сочинений; том XVI–А (1976), p. 64–65.
Chicago
Tchaikovsky, Pyotr Ilyich. “Tchaikovsky to Johann Armsheimer, 28 February / 12 March 1891 (Letter 4340).” Translated by Brett Langston (Tchaikovsky Research). Dear Tchaikovsky. Last updated 18 November 2026. https://deartchaikovsky.com/en/letters/4340/. Printed in П. И. Чайковский. Полное собрание сочинений; том XVI–А (1976), p. 64–65.
BibTeX
@misc{deartchaikovsky-letters-4340,
author = {Pyotr Ilyich Tchaikovsky},
title = {Tchaikovsky to Johann Armsheimer, 28 February / 12 March 1891 (Letter 4340)},
note = {Translated by Brett Langston (Tchaikovsky Research). Printed in П. И. Чайковский. Полное собрание сочинений; том XVI–А (1976), p. 64–65.},
howpublished = {Dear Tchaikovsky},
url = {https://deartchaikovsky.com/en/letters/4340/},
date = {2026-11-18},
}Russian original
28 февр[аля] 1891 г[ода]
г[ород] Клин, Моск[овской] губ[ернии]
с[ело] Фроловское
Многоуважаемый Иван Иванович! Партитуру Вашу я прочёл внимательно и сейчас выскажу Вам моё откровенное о ней мнение. Вы отличный музыкант. Техника Ваша прекрасна (хотя в оркестровке я нахожу некоторую излишнюю густоту красок). Нет ни единого местечка, которое бы хоть сколько-нибудь коробило меня. Все гладко, чисто, изящно. Но у Вас покамест нет никакой индивидуальности, и как Ваше мелодическое, так и гармоническое изобретение — бледны и лишены свежести. Разумеется, я не хочу сказать, что у Вас вовсе нет серьёзного творческого дара; быть может, он впоследствии скажется весьма ощутительно. Но, судя по этой партитуре, я могу покамест лишь констатировать в Вашем музыкальном организме замечательную чуткость, чувство меры и формы, а также весьма основательную, безупречную технику. Ближе всего музыка Вашей оперы подходит к типу так называемой «капельмейстерской музыки». Впрочем, я не имею претензии вещать Вам безусловную истину, а только высказываю, согласно обещанию, своё вполне искреннее мнение.
Во всяком случае Вам следует продолжать писать. Если Вы и не достигнете блестящих результатов, то всё-таки можете обогатить музык[альную] литературу выдающимися произведениями.
Искренно преданный,
П. Чайковский
Партитуру высылаю завтра или послезавтра.
English translation
28 February 1891
Town of Klin, Moscow province
Frolovskoye village
Ivan Ivanovich! I have read through your score [1] carefully and now I will express to my honest opinion of it. Your are a splendid musician. You have a fine technique (although I found some of the orchestration excessively colourful). There is not a single place that was at all jarring to me. Everything is smooth, clean, elegant. But for now you have no individuality whatsoever, and your melodies, as well as your harmonic inventions, are bland and lacking in novelty. Of course I do not want to say that you have no serious creative gift at all; perhaps it will eventually show itself most strikingly. But, for the time being, I can only ascertain from this score that you have an inherent musical sensitivity, a feeling for proportion and form, and also a well-founded, flawless technique. All the music in your opera closely resembles the sort called "kapellmeister music". Nevertheless, I have no pretensions to pronounce a categorical judgement upon you, but merely to express, in accordance with my promise, my wholly sincere opinion.
In any case you should continue to write. Even if you do not achieve brilliant results, then you could still enhance the musical corpus with your outstanding works.
Sincerely devoted,
P. Tchaikovsky
I'm sending the score tomorrow or the next day.
Around this letter
- BeforeSaint Petersburg2 March – 4 March 1891
- HereFrolovskoye6 March – 12 March 1891
- AfterMoscow14 March 1891
Named in this letter
Letters from the same weeks
- 18 February / 2 March 1891 → Anna Merkling
- 19 February / 3 March 1891 → Pyotr Jurgenson
- 20 February / 4 March 1891 → Félix Mackar
- 22 February / 6 March 1891 → Aleksandr Ziloti
- 24 February / 8 March 1891 → Nikolay Konradi
- 25 February / 9 March 1891 → Praskovya Tchaikovskaya
- 25 February / 9 March 1891 → Modest Tchaikovsky
- 2/14 March 1891 → Pyotr Jurgenson
- 8/20 March 1891 → Vladimir Davydov
- 8/20 March 1891 → Anatoly Tchaikovsky
On his desk at the time
- Iolanta 1891
- The Nutcracker 1891–92
- Hamlet 1891
- The Voyevoda 1890–91
- Three Choruses 1891
- Aveu passionné 1891 (?)
- I Don't Know! 1891
- Undina 1878–93
- Les Caprices de Marianne 1878–93
- La Courtisane 1888–91
Published in
- П. И. Чайковский. Полное собрание сочинений; том XVI–А (1976), p. 64–65
Notes
It has not been established which of Johann Armsheimer's works Tchaikovsky had been asked to review.
Sources
Licence: CC BY-NC-SA 4.0. Tchaikovsky Research (en.tchaikovsky-research.net).