Simaki, 9/21 August 1879 · Letter 1246a
To Yury Messer
- From
- Pyotr Ilyich Tchaikovsky
- To
- Yury Messer
- Written at
- Simaki
- Tchaikovsky Research no.
- 1246a
- Translation
- English: Brett Langston (Tchaikovsky Research)
Cite this page
Plain text
Pyotr Ilyich Tchaikovsky. Tchaikovsky to Yury Messer, 9/21 August 1879 (Letter 1246a). Translated by Brett Langston (Tchaikovsky Research). Dear Tchaikovsky, https://deartchaikovsky.com/en/letters/1246a/. Last updated 18 November 2026. Printed in Чайковский. Новые материалы к творческой биографии (2013), p. 219-220 (extracts; with Russian translation, p. 220).
Chicago
Tchaikovsky, Pyotr Ilyich. “Tchaikovsky to Yury Messer, 9/21 August 1879 (Letter 1246a).” Translated by Brett Langston (Tchaikovsky Research). Dear Tchaikovsky. Last updated 18 November 2026. https://deartchaikovsky.com/en/letters/1246a/. Printed in Чайковский. Новые материалы к творческой биографии (2013), p. 219-220 (extracts; with Russian translation, p. 220).
BibTeX
@misc{deartchaikovsky-letters-1246a,
author = {Pyotr Ilyich Tchaikovsky},
title = {Tchaikovsky to Yury Messer, 9/21 August 1879 (Letter 1246a)},
note = {Translated by Brett Langston (Tchaikovsky Research). Printed in Чайковский. Новые материалы к творческой биографии (2013), p. 219-220 (extracts; with Russian translation, p. 220).},
howpublished = {Dear Tchaikovsky},
url = {https://deartchaikovsky.com/en/letters/1246a/},
date = {2026-11-18},
}Original in French
9 Août 1879
Mon cher Monsieur Messer! Permettez[-]moi de Vous remercier pour la peine que Vous Vous êtes donnée d'arranger la partition de piano de mon opéra. Je viens de recevoir votre manuscrit. Permettez[-]moi de Vous dire franchement mon opinion. Votre travail est celui d'un excellent musicien. Vous avez été guidé par un principe très juste — celui d'éviter les difficultés. C'est un principe excellent, mais je trouve que Vous Vous êtes laissé trop influencer par le désir de rendre aussi facile que possible Votre arrangement. Il est un peu trop nu, trop faible, trop transparent je voudrais que l'acte suivant fût un peu plus brillant
Ce qui m'a surtout charmé, c'est que non seulement Vous avez bien fait, mais que Vous avez vite fait, ce qui, chez nous en Russie, est une qualité fort rare
Je serai bien content, mon cher Monsieur Messer, si Vous allez me faire le 2 acte aussi vite que Vous avez fait le 1er
Pardon de ne pas pouvoir Vous écrire en allemand.
English translation
9 August 1879
My dear Monsieur Messer! Allow me to thank you for all the pains you have take upon yourself to arrange the piano score of my opera [1]. I have just received your manuscript. Permit me to tell you my opinion frankly. Your work is that of an excellent musician. You have been guided by a very just principle — that of avoiding difficulties. This is an excellent principle, but I find that you have allowed yourself to be overly influenced by the desire to make your arrangement as simple as possible. It is a little too bare, too thin, too transparent I should like the next act to be a little brighter
What I found particularly charming is that not only did you do it well, but you did it quickly, which for us in Russia is an extremely rare quality
I shall be most content, my dear Monsieur Messer, if you can do the 2nd act as quickly for me as you did the 1st
Forgive me for being unable to write to you in German.
What to listen to
Around this letter
- BeforeKamenka21 July – 20 August 1879
- HereSimaki20 August – 12 September 1879
- AfterSaint Petersburg16 September – 29 September 1879
Named in this letter
Letters from the same weeks
- 30 July / 11 August 1879 → Nadezhda von Meck
- 6/18 August 1879 → Anatoly Tchaikovsky
- 7/19 August 1879 → Modest Tchaikovsky
- 7/19 August 1879 → Pyotr Jurgenson
- 8/20 August 1879 → Anatoly Tchaikovsky
- 8/20 August 1879 → Nadezhda von Meck
- 9/21 August 1879 → Anatoly Tchaikovsky
- 9/21 August 1879 → Modest Tchaikovsky
- 9/21 August 1879 → Pyotr Jurgenson
- 9/21 August 1879 → Nadezhda von Meck
On his desk at the time
- The Maid of Orleans 1878–79
- La Fée 1879 (?)
- Symphony No. 2 1872, 1879–80
- Suite No. 1 1878–79
- Piano Concerto No. 2 1879–80
- Undina 1878–93
- Romeo and Juliet 1878–81 (?)
- Les Caprices de Marianne 1878–93
Published in
- Чайковский. Новые материалы к творческой биографии (2013), p. 219-220 (extracts; with Russian translation, p. 220)
Notes
Messer was helping to make the vocal-piano reduction of The Maid of Orleans.
Sources
Licence: CC BY-NC-SA 4.0. Tchaikovsky Research (en.tchaikovsky-research.net).