Symphony No. 5: compare recordings
The same music in 2 recordings, made between 1934 and 1940. Each bar is one recording of one movement, as long as the performance takes. Play them one after another to hear the difference.
What to listen for
- Tempo. A longer bar usually means a slower performance. Play the first minute of each and listen to how fast the opening goes.
- Rubato. Performers stretch the beat inside a phrase and catch up afterwards. Listen for where a melody holds back before its high note, and where it presses on.
- Cuts and repeats. A bar much shorter than the rest can mean a cut, and a longer one a repeat taken, not only a different speed.
- Recording era. Until 1925 musicians played into a horn; then electrical microphones arrived. A 78 rpm side held about four and a half minutes, so a symphony was recorded in short sections, one disc side at a time.
I. Andante — Allegro con anima
-
Leopold Stokowski 1934
14:59 · 11% slower than the median
-
Artur Rodzinski 1939–40
12:05 · 11% faster than the median
II. Andante cantabile, con alcuna licenza
-
Leopold Stokowski 1934
13:43 · 8% slower than the median
-
Artur Rodzinski 1939–40
11:46 · 8% faster than the median
III. Valse. Allegro moderato
-
Leopold Stokowski 1934
6:00 · at the median
-
Artur Rodzinski 1939–40
5:59 · at the median
IV. Finale. Andante maestoso — Allegro vivace
-
Leopold Stokowski 1934
12:10 · 11% slower than the median
-
Artur Rodzinski 1939–40
9:45 · 11% faster than the median
The recordings
-
Leopold Stokowski, 1934
Philadelphia Orchestra
Horn solo in the second movement: Arthur Berv.
TCHAIKOVSKY: Symphony No. 5 · Licence: CC BY-NC-SA 3.0
-
Artur Rodzinski, 1939–40
Cleveland Orchestra
TCHAIKOVSKY: Symphony No. 5 · Licence: CC BY-NC-SA 3.0
Audio from the Internet Archive, used under the licence shown with each recording. Durations are those of the archive's tracks.