Tchaikovsky and Johannes Brahms
For years Tchaikovsky dismissed Brahms in his letters as dry and overpraised. They met on New Year’s Day 1888 at the violinist Adolph Brodsky’s in Leipzig, and the man disarmed him: modest, kind and fond of a drink. The music still left him cold. They met once more, in Hamburg in March 1889, and never became friends.
Dates and places
1 January 1888 · Leipzig
Tchaikovsky came to dinner at Brodsky’s and found Brahms at the piano, rehearsing his new Piano Trio in C minor, Op. 101, with Brodsky and the cellist Julius Klengel. Edvard and Nina Grieg arrived as the trio ended, and they all sat down to dinner. That evening Brahms conducted his Double Concerto at the Gewandhaus.
12 March 1889 · Hamburg
Brahms, staying in the same hotel, put off his departure by a day to sit through Tchaikovsky’s first rehearsal of the Fifth Symphony. Tchaikovsky reported that he approved of it, though not of all of it: the finale did not please him. Over lunch Tchaikovsky invited him to conduct in Russia, and Brahms declined. He left before the concert on 15 March, and they never met again.
In his letters
“I went on a binge with Brahms; he loves terribly to drink; he's a very kind fellow and not as haughty as I'd imagined.”
“we are awkward with one another because we don't like each other, however, he tries awfully hard to be polite.”
“Did I write that Brahms deliberately stayed an extra day for the symphony, sat through the whole rehearsal, very much approved of the symphony (although not all of it), that we went on a binge, etc.?”
“It is impossible not to respect Brahms; one cannot fail to bow before the chaste purity of his aspirations; one cannot but marvel at his steadfastness and proud refusal to make the least concession to triumphant Wagnerism, but it is difficult to like him.”
In their words
“Where is Tchaikovsky and how is he?”